Отзывы о Монитор Asus VG28UQL1A
287 отзывов пользователей o ASUS VG28UQL1A
Пользовались
ASUS VG28UQL1A?
Поделитесь своим опытом и помогите другим сделать правильный выбор
Robert Morgan
30.01.2023
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
PS5 Gaming Monitor - For Once an Item Worth the Price (if you are able to afford it...)
I'll keep it simple: I now know what PS5 games are supposed to look like.
I am happy to say this is one of the few outrageously expensive items that I am satisfied "the price was worth it". I am fortunate though to have a gaming budget and can save for these kinds of things. I game to offset the stress from my work. And if I am taking the time to game, I want it to be the best experience possible. For the crazy people out there who just want the best monitor (or TV < 32") for whatever the cost, I think this is it for the PS5.
Pros: IMHO, Best monitor (or TV for that matter) for the PS5 at 28". My career is focused on cyber/technology type stuff, and I have plenty of references to have tried prior to ordering this. I put in a lot of research, and this monitor exceeds my expectations.
Cons: Expensive - I decided to get the warranty; I pretty much never do that since tech changes so fast. There will probably be more cons in the future, but ASUS has been good to me. If I'm using this in 5 years as a desktop monitor for work, then it was worth it for me.
NOTE: This review is specifically for the PS5 and does not include Xbox/PC gaming testing. For someone reading this review and wondering about how it looks for anything else, I suspect it will look great.
I am happy to say this is one of the few outrageously expensive items that I am satisfied "the price was worth it". I am fortunate though to have a gaming budget and can save for these kinds of things. I game to offset the stress from my work. And if I am taking the time to game, I want it to be the best experience possible. For the crazy people out there who just want the best monitor (or TV < 32") for whatever the cost, I think this is it for the PS5.
Pros: IMHO, Best monitor (or TV for that matter) for the PS5 at 28". My career is focused on cyber/technology type stuff, and I have plenty of references to have tried prior to ordering this. I put in a lot of research, and this monitor exceeds my expectations.
Cons: Expensive - I decided to get the warranty; I pretty much never do that since tech changes so fast. There will probably be more cons in the future, but ASUS has been good to me. If I'm using this in 5 years as a desktop monitor for work, then it was worth it for me.
NOTE: This review is specifically for the PS5 and does not include Xbox/PC gaming testing. For someone reading this review and wondering about how it looks for anything else, I suspect it will look great.
Justin McIntosh
30.01.2023
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
One line
What did I like or dislike
Burns
30.01.2023
4/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
Terrible Text, Recessed VESA Mount, Wonky Menus
I have 2 of these monitors on my workstation/gaming setup. I replaced 2 older ASUS PB287Q monitors that were showing their age with these. I'm running Windows 10 Pro, GTX1080ti over DisplayPort and noticing that some text looks terrible. I notice it mostly with thinner fonts. I've tried every possible setting on the monitor and in Windows, latest drivers for my graphics card and updated firmware on the monitor. I cannot get the text to look clear. The best way I can describe it is, the text looks like it has red/orange shadows. Some text even looks like its cut off. This makes reading some documents very difficult. I've attempted to take photos of what it looks like, but the camera does not pick up what I can see with my eyes. With Windows HDR enabled, it just makes everything look worse. For me, this is a major dealbreaker since I do a lot of text-related work. I'm running Windows at 100% scaling. I've tried scaling at 125% and 150% (recommended) and it still had no positive change. I am going to have to find a replacement and ship these back while I'm within my return window. The 144Hz refresh rate and size are nice, but what good is it if some aspects ruin it.
The VESA mount is deeply recessed, not flush with the back of the monitor. If you have a mounting plate that slides over the monitor mount, you will have to install the mounting plate on the monitor loose before hanging the monitor on your stand. I have desk mount monitor stands that have this issue.
This monitor has an in-line power brick and not an integrated power supply. Seems like it could have been integrated into the monitor electronics.
The control buttons are located on the side of the monitor. If you have a dual monitor setup, you will be moving the left one a lot if you need to access the menus.
When enabling some features from the monitor's OSD, it disables many others. Its a mickey-mouse system. Once you enable HDR in Windows, you lose the ability to change the brightness and other settings from the monitor.
The VESA mount is deeply recessed, not flush with the back of the monitor. If you have a mounting plate that slides over the monitor mount, you will have to install the mounting plate on the monitor loose before hanging the monitor on your stand. I have desk mount monitor stands that have this issue.
This monitor has an in-line power brick and not an integrated power supply. Seems like it could have been integrated into the monitor electronics.
The control buttons are located on the side of the monitor. If you have a dual monitor setup, you will be moving the left one a lot if you need to access the menus.
When enabling some features from the monitor's OSD, it disables many others. Its a mickey-mouse system. Once you enable HDR in Windows, you lose the ability to change the brightness and other settings from the monitor.
Ziemowit Pierzycki
30.01.2023
8/10
Оценка пользователя
Хорошо
Great minor if you're willing to deal with the flaws
This is a great monitor at a great price. I love the design of the bezel, as it's simple and pretty flat without some strange curves in the back like some other gaming monitors. The picture quality is excellent and the faster frame rate is noticeable over the 60hz monitors. It does what it's supposed to do.
Now for the bad parts. In some of the reviews here, people are complaining about the colors. When you connect the monitor at first, the colors are super saturated. This is not specifically an issue with just this monitor but rather how HDR is handled in general. You have to select "HDR mode" in the graphics settings which correct the colors and in fact give them more volume.
The second issue is with the Display Port. When the monitor goes to sleep, it doesn't wake up properly when moving the mouse. Specifically it turns on, flashes a black screen with "Display Port input" banner and then turns off again. It can be turned on again by using the power button, but this is not how it's supposed to work. I saw several people complaining about it. The fix is to stop using the Display Port and go for HDMI.
Over all, I would but it again.
Now for the bad parts. In some of the reviews here, people are complaining about the colors. When you connect the monitor at first, the colors are super saturated. This is not specifically an issue with just this monitor but rather how HDR is handled in general. You have to select "HDR mode" in the graphics settings which correct the colors and in fact give them more volume.
The second issue is with the Display Port. When the monitor goes to sleep, it doesn't wake up properly when moving the mouse. Specifically it turns on, flashes a black screen with "Display Port input" banner and then turns off again. It can be turned on again by using the power button, but this is not how it's supposed to work. I saw several people complaining about it. The fix is to stop using the Display Port and go for HDMI.
Over all, I would but it again.
April
30.01.2023
6/10
Оценка пользователя
Плохо
Too much white patches
The monitor shows a lot of white patches around edges. We replaced the initial monitor with a replacement. We had the same issues with the light showing through. However on the second monitor we had a vertical 2-3” somewhat visible line traveling the center of the monitor. I would use caution buying new or used.
Kenton Baize
30.01.2023
8/10
Оценка пользователя
Хорошо
Shadow boost looks great. Just need ASUS to not send new monitor with dead pixels
Unlike a TV you sit directly next to monitors and visible dead pixels on a brand new product one intends to use for at least a decade isn't really acceptable new out of box.
If not for the dead pixel literally everything else was as expected, not as bright as mingled back lit style monitor but plenty bright, speakers work, 4k looked great, shadow boost was a surprise bonus that will make those dark environment games so much easier to see on.
(Update, got another one no dead pixels, great looking monitor. The base has pretty long legs, be sure you have a big enough desk space to not hit your mouse into the base.)
ASUS makes some great monitors just send me a 100% working when I buy new and I'd give it 5/5.
If not for the dead pixel literally everything else was as expected, not as bright as mingled back lit style monitor but plenty bright, speakers work, 4k looked great, shadow boost was a surprise bonus that will make those dark environment games so much easier to see on.
(Update, got another one no dead pixels, great looking monitor. The base has pretty long legs, be sure you have a big enough desk space to not hit your mouse into the base.)
ASUS makes some great monitors just send me a 100% working when I buy new and I'd give it 5/5.
michael fenn
30.01.2023
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
PS5
I have never played on anything like this. This makes every other tv/screen I look at seem terrible. I've been gaming for over 20 years and would say this is def worth the money. Maximize your next gen system and buy this thing. I was worried 28 inches would be too small. Its perfect when your 2 feet away from it. I love the gaming/FPS counter function. fast easy way to check or show your friends what's up.
I play in 120 on a PS5. I play Rocket Lg, Call of duty, and MLB the Show. Baseball just recently came out for 120FPS. I am looking forward to all the years I will have with this. All games look fantastic. But I mainly play rocket lg and baseball in 120 FPS. 120 FPS isn't that mind blowing, but yes its def noticeable and needed after you get used to it. Pair that difference with these amazing colors and you have an amazing gaming experience. I'm amazed at when I 1st turn this thing on every time. I would buy this again.
I play in 120 on a PS5. I play Rocket Lg, Call of duty, and MLB the Show. Baseball just recently came out for 120FPS. I am looking forward to all the years I will have with this. All games look fantastic. But I mainly play rocket lg and baseball in 120 FPS. 120 FPS isn't that mind blowing, but yes its def noticeable and needed after you get used to it. Pair that difference with these amazing colors and you have an amazing gaming experience. I'm amazed at when I 1st turn this thing on every time. I would buy this again.
Amazon Customer
30.01.2023
8/10
Оценка пользователя
Хорошо
Not true HDR. Rest is up to spec and good
No local dimming array so not true HDR. Contrast and colors look really good though and having 2 hdmi 2.1 ports is a godsend if you want to plug your computer and a console to it.
Keith Rumney
30.01.2023
4/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
VG28UQL1A is full of firmware related issues, ruin what would be a great monitor
This review is about the VG27UQL1A for which I am pleased with picture quality but in general horrified by many other things that I hope will be fixed with firmware as they ruin my experience:
Problems:
- When connecting it will start playing complete static over the audio for no sensible reason. This is when I am connected to DisplayPort and computer is not outputting audio. In fact the monitor audio settings say it is 0 volume and off. But it will endlessly play static. This annoying drone of static I am currently listening to and has motivated me to write up a bad review logging it's issues, so maybe there is some good coming of it.
- The monitor is smart enough to be incredibly stupid with multiple inputs. I have a work computer on HDMI and a gaming computer on DisplayPort. I restart the gaming computer while monitor is using its DisplayPort and it will immediately switch to HDMI. Then I have to go and switch back to DisplayPort in the monitor settings as it won't switch back on it's own. The monitor doesn't like to switch inputs via the menu and often refuses to do so unless I give it a good 10 seconds between input switches. This is longer than my gaming PC takes to reboot and is very annoying.
- The monitor refuses to let you look at the menu if there is no active connection to a computer. If it isn't connected (or just doesn't think it is) to an active video connection it will immediately go to a standby mode when turning on, and it's impossible to see menu settings. When first turning on the monitor I thought it was broken since I couldn't bring up a menu.
- The monitor often can't be reached or detected by my Windows 10 gaming PC with RX 580. I power cycle my computer several times over and the monitor never connects to my computer. Adding another monitor to the PC reveals it has booted and is functional and the display can't be detected by windows. After 20 minutes of having no idea what is going on the display randomly starts to be detected again.
- The monitor advertises 4k @ 144Hz over DisplayPort but that is only possible if using a DP1.4 connection AND using DSC (compression) otherwise you are over the DP 1.4 bandwidth. However DP 1.4 can support 4k @ 120hz which is close enough, however the monitor EDID doesn't create a profile for that. So the highest setting I can get on my computer which doesn't support DSC is 4k @ 100hz. I had to use the CRU windows tool to force 4k @ 120Hz which works great but should have been available by default for the monitor.
I have had several previous monitors and these issues are all unique to this monitor. I was on V024 firmware and updated to latest V025 firmware but these issues are all still there.
I thought ASUS was a reputable company and time will tell if they fix these but I'm seriously considering returning it given these issues. The hardware all seems decent behind the product but it seems like they fell short seriously on the firmware for the monitor.
Problems:
- When connecting it will start playing complete static over the audio for no sensible reason. This is when I am connected to DisplayPort and computer is not outputting audio. In fact the monitor audio settings say it is 0 volume and off. But it will endlessly play static. This annoying drone of static I am currently listening to and has motivated me to write up a bad review logging it's issues, so maybe there is some good coming of it.
- The monitor is smart enough to be incredibly stupid with multiple inputs. I have a work computer on HDMI and a gaming computer on DisplayPort. I restart the gaming computer while monitor is using its DisplayPort and it will immediately switch to HDMI. Then I have to go and switch back to DisplayPort in the monitor settings as it won't switch back on it's own. The monitor doesn't like to switch inputs via the menu and often refuses to do so unless I give it a good 10 seconds between input switches. This is longer than my gaming PC takes to reboot and is very annoying.
- The monitor refuses to let you look at the menu if there is no active connection to a computer. If it isn't connected (or just doesn't think it is) to an active video connection it will immediately go to a standby mode when turning on, and it's impossible to see menu settings. When first turning on the monitor I thought it was broken since I couldn't bring up a menu.
- The monitor often can't be reached or detected by my Windows 10 gaming PC with RX 580. I power cycle my computer several times over and the monitor never connects to my computer. Adding another monitor to the PC reveals it has booted and is functional and the display can't be detected by windows. After 20 minutes of having no idea what is going on the display randomly starts to be detected again.
- The monitor advertises 4k @ 144Hz over DisplayPort but that is only possible if using a DP1.4 connection AND using DSC (compression) otherwise you are over the DP 1.4 bandwidth. However DP 1.4 can support 4k @ 120hz which is close enough, however the monitor EDID doesn't create a profile for that. So the highest setting I can get on my computer which doesn't support DSC is 4k @ 100hz. I had to use the CRU windows tool to force 4k @ 120Hz which works great but should have been available by default for the monitor.
I have had several previous monitors and these issues are all unique to this monitor. I was on V024 firmware and updated to latest V025 firmware but these issues are all still there.
I thought ASUS was a reputable company and time will tell if they fix these but I'm seriously considering returning it given these issues. The hardware all seems decent behind the product but it seems like they fell short seriously on the firmware for the monitor.
Amazon Customer
30.01.2023
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
Great monitor for price.
It has everything for next gen consoles.
Taylor
30.01.2023
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
Perfect for PS5 COD gaming
Never had a TV or any other monitor with the picture quality of this monitor.
Gabriel Mitchell
30.01.2023
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
Good 4k monitor
Colors seemed washed out, but after getting a color profile from Hardware Unboxed, seems to be ok now.
Jayson
30.01.2023
6/10
Оценка пользователя
Плохо
I really wanted to like this monitor. Had to return it for 2 reasons.
This monitor is a great performer and it does everything it says it does, except for 2 things that bothered me enough to return it.
Issue 1: It won’t wake up on its own when it goes to sleep for longer than 15 minutes. I turn on my PS5 and the monitor simply doesn’t wake up until I press a button on it. That’s not supposed to happen. I found a workaround by setting the PS5 to use HDMI CEC to tell the monitor to shut off, but this forces me to shut down the PS5 as opposed to put it to sleep. It worked okay as a work around but I ultimately gave up on the monitor for issue #2
Issue 2: this monitor has horrible inverse ghosting/overshoot when it’s running at lower refresh rates like 60Hz. Unfortunately, the PS5 forces 60Hz for 99% of its games for most of the time I was dealing with ghosting and teal streaks in the image.
Note: The VG28UQL1A works perfectly with VRR on the PS5. So that’s a plus.
I basically already own the older version of this monitor (VG289Q) which is 4K/60Hz but it has no ghosting issues at all. It’s perfect.
Issue 1: It won’t wake up on its own when it goes to sleep for longer than 15 minutes. I turn on my PS5 and the monitor simply doesn’t wake up until I press a button on it. That’s not supposed to happen. I found a workaround by setting the PS5 to use HDMI CEC to tell the monitor to shut off, but this forces me to shut down the PS5 as opposed to put it to sleep. It worked okay as a work around but I ultimately gave up on the monitor for issue #2
Issue 2: this monitor has horrible inverse ghosting/overshoot when it’s running at lower refresh rates like 60Hz. Unfortunately, the PS5 forces 60Hz for 99% of its games for most of the time I was dealing with ghosting and teal streaks in the image.
Note: The VG28UQL1A works perfectly with VRR on the PS5. So that’s a plus.
I basically already own the older version of this monitor (VG289Q) which is 4K/60Hz but it has no ghosting issues at all. It’s perfect.
Daniel
30.01.2023
6/10
Оценка пользователя
Плохо
Fantastic picture quality, FRUSTRATING bootup issue
My first 4k monitor, the picture quality and framerate are both incredible and perfect for the price and once the system has properly booted it is an incredible monitor. That being said, my rating stays low until ASUS can provide an update to solve the bootup issue. Just wiggling my mouse to wake my PC can take a whole minute of the monitor attempting to connect correctly, over time I have found this more and more frustrating. Please update! I know you can do it ASUS, maybe a setting to disable the auto source finding process of this monitor because I believe that has to do with the issue.
Amazon Customer
30.01.2023
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
Love it
I’ve been using it for a few weeks and I’m very satisfied. It makes my games beautiful on the PS5. I will update my review if anything changes.
Aaron Yamauchi
30.01.2023
6/10
Оценка пользователя
Плохо
Great, but dims regardless of settings. Incredibly annoying.
Enabling Gaming mode on windows 10 fixed the jarring partial lighting on mostly black display. However, despite disabling every setting that offers dynamic dimming or eco mode, the display still dims every few minutes and is unpredictable. There is no set time that would indicate a heating issue. I'm gonna ask ASUS about it, considering how much bloatware they shoved down my throat and the unnecessary BS they've cooked into their hardware like a really bright red LED on my 3090ti when the system is powered off. I don't need to know that it doesn't have enough power when my system is shut down ASUS! Also, my mobo takes forever to start up! Considering these, I'm sure they made dimming a damn feature instead of the annoying bug that it is. Definitely staying away from ASUS in the future.
Armen Avakyan
30.01.2023
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
A great reliable monitor for next gen gaming.
This is a great monitor for 4k gaming and everyday use. I tried using the Samsung Odyssey G7 but had to return it twice, once for clouding and excessive backlight bleed and the second time because it has horrible local diming problems that kept causes flickering issues. This monitor on the other hand hasn't given me any problems, It does have a bit of IPS glow, which is normal for these types of panels. I honestly don't really have any complaints about it, It has a variety of HDMI ports, which is awesome because it means I can plug in all of my consoles without having to buy an HDMI splitter. The picture quality is really clear and the colors are vibrant, I've tried it out on every console and pc, Both work flawlessly. It's fantastic with all the new gen consoles and definitely worth it if you want a reliable monitor. I just wish it was a bit cheaper, but these types of monitors are pretty expensive since it's new technology. Having it at 28 inches is perfect for me but I know most people would prefer a 32 inch 4k monitor.
Dianne
30.01.2023
8/10
Оценка пользователя
Хорошо
Good monitor for PS5
The one thing I did not like is the box has damage holes on it... For the price I paid for the monitor I think it should have handled a lil better... The good thing is the monitor wasn't damage...
TJ
30.01.2023
6/10
Оценка пользователя
Плохо
Dead Pixel
It's pretty disappointing to find a dead pixel after only 5 months of use.
Dustan
30.01.2023
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
This Monitor with my PS5 looks so beautiful.
The color pops and the picture quality running with my PS5 this monitor was made for me.
Love it, couldn’t ask for a better monitor.
I’m a happy customer. This thing rocks. Anyone looking for a monitor for ps5 or Xbox series S or series X, this is the monitor for you.
Blow away the competition with this baby.
10 outta 10. 💯 😁❤️
Love it, couldn’t ask for a better monitor.
I’m a happy customer. This thing rocks. Anyone looking for a monitor for ps5 or Xbox series S or series X, this is the monitor for you.
Blow away the competition with this baby.
10 outta 10. 💯 😁❤️
Phillip King
30.01.2023
6/10
Оценка пользователя
Плохо
Meh, definitely not worth the price
It’s definitely 4K, but I’ve seen 1440p monitors with better quality and responsiveness compared to this one.
Amazon Customer
30.01.2023
8/10
Оценка пользователя
Хорошо
Beautiful but use headphones
Great picture quality, but the volume leaves much to be desired. Had to buy additional external speakers to be able to watch anything from any amount of distance at all, even with the volume jacked all the way up on all levels (browser sound, system sound, actual media sound).
Brad M
30.01.2023
8/10
Оценка пользователя
Хорошо
Very happy!
This works as it should and the picture is perfect. My only complaint is the difficulty in changing inputs. Other than that, I love this monitor.
David.J.L
30.01.2023
4/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
Blk Friday Deal but it’s secondary Sales item.
Nice gaming monitor but not a good dealer. I bought this item on black Friday, and the price was $509.99. When I received the package, it looks like a secondary sale, with a lot of packaging tape on the box, and the same inside, I mean if just like this, I don't mind. But it has a broken pixel on the screen!!! That pissed me off. Because of the packaging tape, the box was broken when I open it, so I throw away and the garbage truck toke it, so maybe I can’t return it.
Показаны отзывы 193-216 из 287.
