Отзывы о Жесткий диск Seagate Barracuda 1 ТБ ST31000528AS
668 отзывов пользователей o Seagate Barracuda 1 ТБ ST31000528AS
Пользовались
Seagate Barracuda 1 ТБ ST31000528AS?
Поделитесь своим опытом и помогите другим сделать правильный выбор
Большаков Андрей
26.02.2010
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
- + Тихий, не греется, отличное соотношение цена/качество
- - Не нашёл
Сначала были проблемы с установкой, но это проблемы материнки. Перевёл хард в режим SATA1 и всё заработало...
Скроменый эксперт
10.09.2009
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
- + Тихий как сигейт-макстор stm3250310as, то есть оочень тихий для такого харда. Шустрый, прекрасно справляется с кучей одновременных закачек, торрентов, и прочего хлама. Температура 30 градусов в охлаждаемой корзинке среди множества других хардов (у остальных больше).
- - И правда, имеет место громкий старт..но это только старт)))
По всем параметрам отличный хард. Пришел на смену 500-гиговому st3500320ns, и ничуть не уступает ему в быстродействии (!). После таких моделей любовь к сигейту не знает...
saharovich sahar
09.09.2009
2/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
- + тихий.
- - люди это какашко!
хорошие отзывы оставляют те кто не сканил этот диск на ошибки. есть более достойные производители с более качественными продуктами!
купил, принёс, поставил.
определился правильно. попытался установить систему - стала. но пару раз выбрасывала ошибку что не найден какойто файл. запустил тесты на ночь и утром офи..ел. куча бэдов, куча реллокейтов! затирать битые сектора не стал, просто отнёс продавцу...
определился правильно. попытался установить систему - стала. но пару раз выбрасывала ошибку что не найден какойто файл. запустил тесты на ночь и утром офи..ел. куча бэдов, куча реллокейтов! затирать битые сектора не стал, просто отнёс продавцу...
Столбун Дмитрий
25.01.2010
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
- + Оч быстрый, на 2х платинах, тихий. Щелкает только при выключении, в работе какого либо некомфортного шума не замечено, комп прямо над ухом)...
bali8844
26.11.2009
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
- + Всё прекрасно!! производительность, бусшумность,нагрева почти нет, всё летает!!!
- - не заметил))))
Купил мес назад... До этого на новом железе стоял 3х годовалый 250Гб WD. Этот по сравнению-самолёт. Всю критику этого девайса...
Купцов Максим
14.10.2009
8/10
Оценка пользователя
Хорошо
- + Тихий (больше пока сказать не могу)
- - Щелчек при старте
Косяк в том что на платформе AMD видится объём всего 33mb (Firmware CC37). (пробывал на материнках Gigabaite...
Королев Дмитрий
22.10.2009
8/10
Оценка пользователя
Хорошо
- + 2 пластины, не греется, хорошая цена.
- - Громко стартует. При активном обращении работает тоже громко: перемещал на него...
Скроменый эксперт
09.10.2009
4/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
- + Единственное достоиноство,принадлежность к известному имени.
- - Очень шумный.
При каждом обращении к диску,появляется довольнотаки громкий скрежет.Думал неисправность,с трудом обменял на такую-же модель - с ужасом услышал тоже самое,придётся привыкать.
Захаров Андрей
06.09.2009
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
- + 1)Нереально тихий(даже забываешь о нем)
2)Легко подключить
3)Не греется - - Единственный недостаток-при включении раздаётся довольно громкий щелчок.
Лично я очень...
Коробко Сергей
13.08.2009
4/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
- + Нет
- - Не совместим со стационарными медиаплеерами (скорее всего опять не доработали прошивку). Громкий старт.
Покупался для установки в стационарный медиаплеер. Не совместим с...
Стеценко Слава
26.04.2009
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
- + Террабайтник, причём не дорогой
- - Пока не нашёл, кроме (как у всех производиетелей) маркетингового хода, не ведающих, что в килобайте не 1000 байт, а 1024, и т.д, т.е реальная ёмкость 931Гиг
Пляска с бубном несколько имела место, но это мои тараканы, так что к недостаткам нельзя отнести, ибо комп у меня старый, 7 лет, диски IDE , в PCI слот можно поставить только SATA1...
Матвеенко Александр
15.04.2009
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
- + Имеет две пластины по 500 гб.
Холоднее аналогов (25-32 градуса С) в работе, что на 10-15 градусов ниже предыдущей 11-ой серии.
Очень тихий
Прошивка без ранних проблем.
Относится к 12-ой серии. Заметно Быстрее...
Зубрийчук Максим
29.04.2009
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
- + Шустрый, тихий, холодный, недорогой. В общем, одна радость.
- - Не заметил.
Стоят Сигейты 160 (два года), 320 (год), 500 (полгода) и 1000...
Вадим
12.12.2023
4/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
Плохая модель
- + Отлично отработал 3 года.
- - Стал притормаживать показал нестабильные сектора и сразу после перезагрузки сдох. Не читает не виндовс не диски восстановления (стрелец, виктория). Диск использовался как архив.
Евгений А.
12.12.2023
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
Отличная модель
- + Диску 12 лет, все еще работает.
- - Есть треск при старте.
Та Ка
12.12.2023
2/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
Очень плохая модель
- + Красивый снаружи
- - Перестал стартовать, при запуске пытается раскрутить шпиндель но не может, такое не в первый раз, Seagate не берите, WD надёжнее.
Скроменый эксперт
22.01.2013
4/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
In the past, I had much better luck with Seagate drives than with Western Digital. I think any more, they're pretty much on equal footing, with proponents and detractors for each brand.This review isn't so much about the drive itself as it is about trying to replace one under warranty. This isn't a sour grapes review, I'm only writing it to let others know what they can expect if they attempt to replace a drive under warranty.My existing drive failed Seatools, and was not repairable. Since I wasn't in any particular hurry to get the drive back, I got an RMA (order number) from Seagate, scrounged up a box and acceptable foam padding and shipped the original drive back on 12/15/2012. I received an acknowledgement that they had received my drive on 12/28/2012. The replacement was shipped on 1/3/2013 and was delivered on 1/9/2013. I ran Seatools short test, which passed. At this point I reloaded the OS and did all the updates to use as a testbed. A couple days later, I decided to run Seatools long test which takes approximately 2 ? hours to complete. At the end, the drive failed with something n the neighborhood of 100 bad blocks, which I repaired. I then re-ran the long test and had another 100 or so bad bocks, which I also repaired. I then attempted a full erase, which failed also. I attempted to contact tech support during their normal working hours via both live chat and phone. No one was available .At that point I decided to RMA this drive also. Rather than ship the drive back and wait for another, I decided to use the "Premium Advanced Replacement", which is supposed to include 2 day shipping and a prepaid return shipping label. The price is reasonable at $9.95, considering that the UPS shipping on the first drive was almost that much. I placed this order on 1/12/13.In the meantime, I decided to re-run Seatools long test and see how many failures the "repaired" drive had. It took 6 runs to get a no failures result, which is over 400 bad blocks. At the time I placed the order for the second warranty drive I didn't realize that Seatools stops at 100 or so bad blocks. I only figured that out later. In the over all scheme of things, I'm not sure how common that many bad blocks is, but I wasn't willing to accept a repaired drive with that many defects.Anyway, back to the saga... The 2nd replacement was finally shipped on 1/17/13 and arrived on 1/21/13.The bottom line is, so far I've spent about $20.00 on shipping, spent a lot of hours repairing an already repaired drive, and what I have now is a used drive that was sent back to Seagate for some unknown problem which I'll never fully trust. All that for a drive that I could probably buy new for $75.00. Thanks, but next time I'll take a pass on all this and go with new.The bottom line is that the drive is worth a 3, since I don't think WD drives are any better or worse. The warranty replacement process gets a very generous 2.
Скроменый эксперт
07.05.2012
2/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
Length:: 1:02 MinsThis drive (the 750 GB version) failed completely in 8 days. It made the much reported, very loud clicking noise on day 7 and failed completely on day 8 with the same noise. Seagate's Seatools diagnostic utility said the drive was fine and passed all tests when I ran it after the loud noise on day 7 - it tempoarily worked for a brief period of time. The failure of Seagate's Seatools to report serious problems with it's own drives has also been much reported. And compounding that, Seagate states that if its diagnostics pass, then the drive is OK (!!!) - clearly and obviously not the case.This is the second recent Seagate hard drive to fail completely within one month on a PC I maintain. I have also had a Seagate Flex drive fail in 4 days. I maintain a total of about 12 PCs, a few from Dell, and only the recent Seagate drives have failed. And they have failed so soon after first use. I personally, and others I work with and have talked to, can unfortunately no longer trust any drive from Seagate. I haven't bought a Seagate drive in 18 months (not counting the failed Flex drive) due to the reported problems and won't until I am sure their problems are under control, but Dell continues to use them in their desktops and so I run into these failing drives. This Seagate that failed was in a RAID 0 array and could have lost the 800+ GBs stored on the array if it had not been all backed up to an external drive, a move I insisted on when I saw the drives were Seagate drives.I have added a video to let people hear the clicking sound the drive generally makes when it fails. If you hear this sound it may be too late to copy any data off it, but on both the failing Seagates I saw the drive came back for a day or two after the noise before failing completely (noise continuous, drive not operational at all). Absolutely stop putting any critical data on the drive, and NO MATTER what Seagate's diagnostic utility programs say: stop using the drive. The drive in the video passed Seagate's diagnostics, getting 100% green on every "test", when it temporarily worked after first making that noise.Please Seagate: fix the problems with your hard drives and make reliable drives again - I used your drives for 15+ years without problems (at least no more than any other drives). At last ccount about 130 of the 600 reviews on this drive were 1 star! That is beyond atrocious, espeically given the consequences so many will face if the drive fails.
Скроменый эксперт
02.08.2011
2/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
BACKGROUND: Seagate Barracuda 750GB hard drive on our PC started going bad after a mere year and a half. No data loss, but drive would intermittently "freeze up" the computer so it might, for example, take 2 minutes to launch an application. (I found out later on the internet that other people have had similar problems with the drive and that it might be a design flaw.)PROPOSED SOLUTION: Buy the exact same drive from Amazon Prime, and with $3-$4 overnight shipping, I can have it in 24 hours. With the exact same drive, I knew there would be no compatibility problems - should be pop in and go, right?PACKAGING: I know I'm supposed to provide feedback on this separately, but... lots of others have commented, multiple years ago, on the poor packing job. I assumed by 2011 Amazon would have fixed it, right? Apparently not - item was still shipped in tiny box with minimal padding. This may have contributed to its failure. (Ironically, almost everything else we've ever ordered from Amazon has been overkill on packaging. Maybe they're just inexperienced with sensitive electronics.)SURPRISE: The drive I received was actually marked as a refurbished drive! I bought it "new" from Amazon. I didn't bother reading the fine print, so I can't tell you if "new" means truly new or "new refurbished."VERDICT: Upon booting the PC, the Bios complained that the drive status was "bad". I continued the boot and tried using it anyway. It worked for about 15 minutes, then the drive disappeared from Windows Explorer... Windows failed to recognize it. Rebooted, and same thing: Worked for a short time, then disappeared.RESOLUTION: So much for my "easy" Amazon solution. After reading further poor Seagate reviews, and after being disappointed with TWO Seagates now, I decided to go with Western Digital. On Amazon WD's are generally $20 more, which I'd gladly be willing to pay for a better drive. BUT... Best Buy sells WD's at Seagate prices, and also sells mostly WD's and only a few Seagates, which tells you something. Bought the new Caviar Green 1GB hard drive. I had to drive 40 miles to the store to buy this. BUT... worked PERFECTLY first time. It's now been several weeks, NO problems with the drive whatsoever. I would definitely recommend Western Digital over Seagate.RETURN: We tried to use the Amazon website to return the dead Barracuda, but that part of the website didn't work (ironically, the ONLY part we've ever had a problem with). Tried other browsers, too. So had to Email Amazon customer service. We are pleased to report, though, that they promptly sent us a return authorization, we shipped the drive back, and we did get a full refund without hassle (aside from the initial website problem). So kudos to Amazon for this.
Скроменый эксперт
26.01.2013
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
My parents ASUS computer died. They bought a new computer and were throwing out the one that died. I told them I would take the computer and see if I could fix whatever the problem was. Turned out it was just the hard drive. I ordered the original drive for replacement which was this Seagate Barracuda 7200 1 TB. It arrived at my doorstep 3 days after ordering via standard mail delivery. Although I've never replaced a hard drive before, it literally took 10 minutes to take the housing off the tower, remove 4 screws, undo the data & power cables replace the hard drive and reassemble the unit. Installed the recovery disc and the computer was back to original condition in minutes. I've had no issues since installing this hard drive and the parents now have their own computers instead of sharing. Well worth the $83.00
Скроменый эксперт
09.04.2013
4/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
First of all, this HDD was my "backup" hdd for all the other hdd's that have died on me. I forgot to create a backup for my backup so now I have no backups. I am pretty angry to lose all of my backups.I bought this hdd from another place on 9/16/2008 and it officially started to make clicking noises on 4/1/2013 or so and is dead.
Скроменый эксперт
07.04.2013
4/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
Great warranty service, which I have used twice now. I bought two of these drives and both failed once. I sent in a warranty claim and they replaced both of them. I would not recommend them as 2 out of 2 have failed. If you do use it, be sure to back up your data.
Скроменый эксперт
27.03.2013
2/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
The delivery and item itself went as expected.I plugged the drive into my raid arrary and it went online precisely as expected.However, only 3 months after plugging it in the device has failed and I have to replace. This was not a good investment.
Скроменый эксперт
16.08.2009
8/10
Оценка пользователя
Хорошо
Here is my review of the OEM, Seagate 12th series ST31000528AS 1 TB Barracuda dual platter perpendicular recording very spaciousg SATA desktop hard drive. This particular drive comes with platters with density level of 500 GB each. For this model line, there are various sizes ranging from 160 GB to 1 TB in size. I've noticed particularly, larger capacity drives comes in SATA only. It's getting harder and harder to buy a hard drive in the EIDE form, because EIDE interface is on its way out. It's being phased out by most hard drive manufacturer as well as computer motherboard manufacturer. For those of you with older computers that has only EIDE interface, you may be able to connect your computer to a SATA hard drive or optical drive by using a converter card. This card is inserted in the back of the hard drive converting a SATA drive to EIDE.I've purchased this drive to use as storage only, and petition it as one large petition of 931 GB. After installation of this drive on my computer, I use Seagate's excellent free DiscWizard software to petition the hard drive. The process is relatively quick unlike using Windows to do this. I've downloaded this hard drive utility program from the Seagate website. This is a 128 MB download and may take a while on a slower Internet connection. This program will only run if you have at least a Seagate or Maxtor hard drive on board. This hard drive utility program is really a stripped-down version of Acronis True Image Home. Partly because of this excellent utility program that I decided to stick with Seagate instead of defecting to Western Digital instead for this purchase. With this program, you can clone your old hard drive to the new under Windows or using the bootable CD R which you can make with this program. You can use this program to backup your entire hard drive as well and save it on your storage drive. If anything should happen to your Windows installation, all you would have to do is to restore it using this program in its entirety. Doing it this way, you would not have to install Windows plus updates and all of the programs that you use all over again. You can do this by just simply inserting the bootable CD, restart the computer and then follow the prompts to restore your computer. Unlike previous programs of this nature, this program does an excellent job of it. After the cloning or restore, everything appears to work fine. In my example for instance using maximum compression, I was able to save my 37 GB which was the total of my "C" Windows petition as a 19 GB file on my storage drive. This unreliable problem with the 11th series because its firmware problems which hurt Seagate's reputation tremendously. It's also because of that, that Seagate reduced the warranty from five years to three for consumer grade hard drives. Although, the server class NS series hard drives still remains at five years warranty. According to some of the professional reviews, they reported that this hard drive is extremely fast in fact almost as fast as one running at 10,000 RPM. I tried benchmarking this hard drive using Sandra. The test result shows a starting point at 129 MB a second read speed with a drive index of 102. The test results shows that this hard drive is slightly faster than my previous 11th series Seagate hard drive. This hard drive runs extremely quiet and relatively cool with temperature not exceeding 32°C on my computer so far. This is about 5°C less when compare with my previous hard drive installed in the same position under the same conditions. This according to Hard Disk Sentinel, the hard drive monitoring program. Because of the fast read and write speed of this hard drive as well as my previous one which was the Seagate 11th series, I was able to copy my files over from my old to this one in relatively short time. The old drive will be installed on my old computer to be used as storage or as Windows drive.Update July 17, 2009: So far, This drive has been performing extremely well and I am quite happy with the performance. Since purchased, according to S.M.A.R.T. I have 164 hours on the clock. It hasn't produced any unusual noises or other glitches.Update August 16, 2009: According to S.M.A.R.T. the hard drive had a minor problem, one reallocated section moved to the spare section. Other than this, the drive still works extremely well. As long as I'm not getting more new bad sections constantly it should be all right. Regardless of what, I think Seagate is slipping in quality control. Even the best of hard drives comes manufactured with bad section, that get mapped out during the first initialization process at the factory so it doesn't show up under S.M.A.R.T.. This is usually the case, why when you receive the drive it appears perfect.
Показаны отзывы 121-144 из 668.
