Отзывы о Жесткий диск Seagate Barracuda 160 ГБ ST3160318AS
Краткие характеристики:
- Barracuda 7200.12
- 3.5"
- SATA 3Gb/s
- 160 Гб
- 7200 rpm
- буфер 8 Мб
 |
Жесткий диск Seagate ST3160318AS 160Gb SATAII 3,5" HDD | Яндекс Маркет | 2 915 ₽ | Посмотреть |
Плюсы по отзывам пользователей - Почему стоит купить Seagate Barracuda 160 ГБ ST3160318AS?:
- Высокая скорость чтения и записи:
- Достигает 110-117 МБ/с по тестам HD Tach, сравнимо с Samsung Spinpoint F3.
- Отлично справляется с потоковым видео, играми и копированием больших файлов в RAID-массивах.
- Быстрее IDE-дисков, подходит для основного диска или хранения HD-видео.
- Большая ёмкость по низкой цене за ГБ:
- 1.5 ТБ за минимальную стоимость на момент покупки (0.085$/ГБ).
- Идеально для хранения фильмов, фото и резервных копий, вмещает сотни видео.
- Лучшее соотношение цена/ёмкость среди 7200 об/мин дисков.
- Низкое энергопотребление и низкая температура:
- Работает на 20-30 Вт в RAID, на 3-4°C холоднее WD enterprise-дисков.
- Быстро выходит из спящего режима, подходит для NAS и серверов.
- Не нагревается в хорошо вентилируемых корпусах.
- Стабильная работа поздних ревизий с firmware CC1H:
- После обновления firmware работает годами без сбоев (до 2-3 лет в RAID).
- Подходит для NAS (D-Link DNS-321, QNAP, Thecus), стриминга видео по сети.
- Проходит тесты SeaTools и SMART без ошибок у многих пользователей.
- Низкая вибрация и приемлемый шум в простое:
- Тише WD Caviar Black в некоторых тестах, незаметен через корпус.
- Меньше вибрации, чем у Spinpoint F3, не требует изоляции.
- Подходит для HTPC и медиа-серверов.
- Хорошая гарантия и RMA-процесс:
- 5 лет гарантии, быстрая замена через Seagate (2 недели).
- Поддержка высылает UPS-лейблы для возврата.
Минусы по отзывам пользователей:
- Частые отказы и "щелчки смерти":
- 20-30% отказов в первые месяцы, click of death, bad sectors после 100-800 часов.
- Умирают внезапно, приводят к потере данных даже в RAID.
- Замены тоже ломаются (refurbished диски выходят из строя за 6 недель).
- Проблемы с firmware ранних ревизий:
- SD1x/CC1x вызывают зависания, dropout из RAID, замедление до 1/4 скорости.
- Обновление не всегда помогает, иногда "кирпичит" диск.
- Несовместимость с -301/-302 ревизиями, Seagate меняет firmware месяцами.
- Громкий шум и вибрация:
- Высокий писк, громкие щелчки при поиске, buzzing на старте (громче Raptor).
- Шум усиливается при заполнении >80% или многозадачности.
- Заметен на расстоянии, мешает в HTPC и тихих системах.
- Нестабильность в RAID и NAS:
- Зависания на 10-30 сек из-за cache flush, вылет из RAID5/6.
- Проблемы в Drobo, ReadyNAS, Synology; не рекомендуется для RAID без фиксов.
- Несколько дисков ломаются одновременно в массиве.
- Плохая упаковка Amazon:
- Диски болтаются в коробке без фиксации, приводят к DOA или повреждениям.
- Повреждённые платы, антистатические пакеты с дырками.
- Лучше заказывать у Newegg или с retail-упаковкой.
- Слабая поддержка Seagate и перегрев:
- Поддержка игнорирует месяцами, добавляет в mailing list вместо помощи.
- Перегрев в USB-доках или без вентиляции (до 43-50°C).
235 отзывов пользователей o Seagate Barracuda 160 ГБ ST3160318AS
Пользовались
Seagate Barracuda 160 ГБ ST3160318AS?
Поделитесь своим опытом и помогите другим сделать правильный выбор
Квазар-9YRHC
25.12.2017
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
- + Надёжность, не поверите, работает 10 (десять) лет нет сбоев, до этого я сменил 3 винта
- - конечно устарел...
Астрон-4ULZZ
25.08.2013
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
- + Надежный, холодный, тихий
- - маленький обьем, не самая высокая производительность
Немного устаревшая модель,...
Капеллан-4YOTN
19.08.2024
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
Отличная модель
Эксопилот-6QEHW
13.01.2022
8/10
Оценка пользователя
Хорошо
Хорошая модель
- + Пережил 11 лет то есть с 2011.08 по 2022 и тихий.
- - У всех вроде нормально но у моего походу появились битые сектора и комп тормозит...
Супернова-5AJUR
11.08.2012
4/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
I bought 3 of these drives for a RAID 0 array on my main computer on Sep 10, 2009. One of those drives failed yesterday (Aug 10, 2012), approximately 3 years after purchase.I use my computer more than average as I work from home and my computer runs multiple virtual machines all the time. And the same computer is used for video gaming after work, on average about 12 hours a day, 7 days a week.I have expected these drives to last longer than 3 years (was expecting 5 at least), disappointed with the reliability.They are very fast and have large capacity though, but if you run these drives heavily, plan to replace them at around the 3 year mark.
Спектр-3MAQJ
25.06.2012
2/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
As soon as I saw the packaging I knew I made a horrible choice. The cardboard it was "secured" in was held together by a single scotch tape. Without really looking at the product after opening the package, I mounted the hard drive into my brand new build Mac Pro. The machine started up fine but the Hard Drive started making spinning noises ever 2 seconds or so, like it was trying to spin, but couldn't, then repeats the process til it just finally stop spinning altogether. Thinking it was the problem with not enough voltage from the power supply, I tried it again with only the motherboard and the hard drive plugged up to the power supply. Same. Damn. Issue.After taking it back out the casing, I took a closer look at the hard drive. The green board on the bottom is CRACKED. Seriously...Enough said.
Туманник-1JEGU
04.06.2012
2/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
After installing a fresh copy of Windows 7 on this drive, I stared downloadingThe MS Windows updates in clumps of around 10 to 12 at a time and doing rebootsIn between each clump. I always install all versions of Windows this way becausethere is no way I'm trusting Microsoft to install 90 to 112 updates on my system at one time!Well; as it goes, my hard drive stopped booting after 5 or so hours of loading drivers and updates.I barely started the software installs and didn't even get a chance to load anti-virus software.NO BOOT DEVICE FOUND!Replaced the SATA cable and checked the Power Connector. No Boot! Connected the 3year old 750-GB Hitachi Drive back to my system, and it boots fine. What a piece of junk! A complete drive failure after less than one quarter of a day.
Астрон-0LARS
21.01.2009
2/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
Update Review on September 22, 2009 **** 4 Stars===================================================At the beginning of this year, I wrote a scathing review of this product after numerous problems. To summarize, Seagate had a total mess on their hands with 3 different hardware revisions and over a dozen firmwares out in the span of a couple months. There were massive problems, and Seagate tech support was completely overwhelmed. I had problems of drives freezing, terrible noises on start up, reallocated sectors, and the "click of death".Fast forward. I have had the latest hardware revision -302 with firmware CC1H on 3 drives for about 8 months. These have had NO problems. I just purchased my 4th of these drives from Amazon a couple days ago, and I can confirm they are still -302 hardware and CC1H firmware. This latest one was very well packed by Amazon in a "manufacturer-type" drive box. No issues with the current packaging (although some in the past from Amazon were questionable). A full surface scan came up with no errors. I have added a customer image of my oldest drive. It is important to realize that the massive complaints of problems and failures could be with the earlier hardware revisions and firmware.I can't give this product 5 stars due to the past problems, and because there are no guarantees the ones I have won't fail before the warranty is up. (The new 2TB green drives are now having massive failures/problems.) Of the 3 I have, only 1 has "normal" hours on it, as the other 2 were backup only. I have had other drives fail in the past couple years including a WDC Raptor, a WDC laptop drive, and a Deskstar, so I believe this last version is no worse than others out there.One thing to recognize with modern drives is that they are no way as reliable as their MTBF reliability specs indicate. Hard drives are dirt cheap these days and drive manufacturers are hurting. Solid state drives will only hurt them more. I now look at drives as disposable, and keep several backups. This drive finally looks stable and has a very low cost per GB along with enough capacity to last you several more years.Previous Review====================================================================There is a fair amount of misinformation in various reviews. First, these are 4-platter drives. Next, they are part of the Seagate 7200.11 series. Both this drive and the 1TB have serious issues. Seagate support is completely overwhelmed. If you do not know about these, just surf forums dot seagate dot com for literally hundreds of pages of problems.I had purchased two of these after reading that firmware bugs had been finally worked out with SD1A. To give you an idea, Seagate has gone though something like SD13, SD14, SD15, SD17, SD19, SD35, SD37, and SD1A. The only problem is that while the model number of this product is ST31500341AS, the part number is 9JU138-XXX, and SD1A only works on 9JU138-300 drives. I received one 9JU138-301 and one 9JU138-302 which are apparently, incompatible, different hardware revisions. These latter drives use firmware revisions including CC1F, CC1G, CC1H, and CC1J where people are experiencing similar and different problems. There is such a mess of problems with these drives that Seagate support can't even keep up.To make a long story short, one of my drives makes a terrible buzzing sound on power-up which has been reported by others. Otherwise, it worked seemingly OK for a week or so. Now, I get random read/write stalls, and I get the now-famous "click of death" where the drive makes loud clicking sounds and crashes the system. Drive SMART reports no errors, but that's B.S. I bought these for backup drives, yet I cannot trust them, so what's the point? I am waiting for Seagate to respond to my inquiries (email and support form) before I return them.Based on the stories I had read in late December, I thought these drives were out-of-the-woods, so to speak, but they are not.Update: Still no response from Seagate on my 2 inquiries. Now the drive is reporting (bad) reallocated sectors. Time for a different brand. Scary amount of problems with less than 100 hours on the drive.Update: Another week and no response from Seagate. There were some rumors on their forums that their email server crashed, and that's why they weren't responding. Hello? They're a drive company. Don't they have a backup? Maybe the server used these new Seagate drives ;) FWIW, Seagate SD1A is not "out of the woods". There is now SD1B. Seagate claims that there is no need to update CC or LC firmware, but I and the forums say otherwise. There is no upgraded firmware *available* if you have a -301 or -302 drive. They are still fixing the -300 drives.Update: Finally got a response from Seagate after 3 weeks! Seems what they do is not really assist you but add your email to a mailing list which directs you to their support website for updates. My CC1H is behaving OK, but not my CC1G. According
Вояджер-5KUGI
08.07.2009
2/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
If you do NOT value your time, money or data - then I highly recommend this drive. For everyone else - STAY AWAY!As I said in the title, I truly wish I could give this drive 0 stars, and 0 stars for Seagate's support procedures, too (emphasis on procedures - I have nothing against their support reps). I've used dozens of hard drives from many different vendors over the years (including WD, Seagate, Toshiba, Fujitsu), some were better and some were worse - but I never came close to experience anything quite like what I experienced here.Bottom line - both the original drive I purchased, as well as the replacement drive I received - crashed within a couple of months of fairly low usage. Read on if you'd like the full details.When I first bought the drive, it was towards the end of 2008, when Seagate was already acknowledging an issue, and began providing new firmwares. I figured that a big company like Seagate won't be able to afford not-to-fix that issue, and decided the buy the drive despite the negative reports. A clear mistake.Within several days after purchase I started experiencing the same symptoms people were reporting - the drive slows to a halt, disappears from Windows, and also began to 'develop' a handful of bad sectors. Upgrading the firmwares (multiple times, as they were released) seemed to improve the situation - but didn't really. After less than 4 months, the drive died completely failing to spin up and manifesting the dreaded click of death.It was the first time ever a drive failed on me while in warranty (discounting a drive that crashed when I dropped my laptop a few years ago - which was completely my fault), so it was an unpleasant surprise to receive a refurbished drive in return. It was the very first time in my life (around 20 years of relevance) that I had a refurbished drive in any of my systems. I checked the firmware to make sure it's not supposed to be affected - and it wasn't. Long story short - exactly the same thing happened with this refurbished drive, only this time it only took 6 weeks. During these 6 weeks - as the same old symptoms that happened with the 1st drive began to repeat themselves, I contacted Seagate's support and asked them what I can do to avoid losing >1.1TB of data again. Their response was simply that these are good drives, that just a few bad sectors and a couple of spinup problems don't mean much, but that I can RMA it if I'd like.Soon thereafter, what I predicted would happen actually happened and the drive died (exact same symptoms; failing to spin up, click of death). Thankfully I was backing it up most of it to another drive on a daily basis due to lack of trust, so I hardly lost any data. I contacted Seagate's support and asked what I need to do in order to get a brand new drive, recently manufactured - so that it might actually live to celebrate it's first birthday instead of dying so prematurely. Their answer was simple and consistent - sorry, no can do, we can only give you another refurbished drive, and don't worry about it - they're fine.Telling them I have next to no faith in the model, but *absolutely no faith* in another refurbished drive from the same model was of no help. "We'll be happy to send you another refurbished drive". Why Seagate expects users to be willing to trust their data with these faulty drives is beyond me - after two failures in such a short timeframe, the burden of proof should be on THEM.I have my principles, and I refuse to spend more time on these faulty drives, especially if I have no reason to believe they'd be any better than the 100% failure rate I've seen so far (for me - a drive from a new batch *might* be better and worth a shot - but I'm only considering it because I'm already 'invested' in this drive; If you haven't bought one yet - simply STAY AWAY!). Like I told Seagate, this drive will be going to the trash can, I'll swallow the $'s lost, and do my best to prevent others from falling to the same pitfall.By the way - my system is properly cooled, and the drives never went above 43C. I have 2 other WD drives in the very same system that, touch wood, have been working without a single hiccup for over two years.If I helped prevent even one person from throwing money, but more importantly - time and data - at this drive, then it was worth writing this review.
Квантум-0EQGA
03.09.2012
2/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
Out of three identical drives I purchased, one failed after 3 weeks, and another one failed after 2 years. Luckily I am running a RAID 1 so I had no data loss, but I definitely think these are junk. Poor customer support too. Shame on you Seagate!
Пульсар-2DXTY
03.07.2012
4/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
I ordered several of these drives and they lasted for about a year and a half, then both failed within 2 months of each other. I have had 5 Seagate drives fail in the last year and a half, and the oldest one was a little over 500 days old. Good-bye Seagate...Hello WD.
Зета-Орион-9VXPT
15.06.2012
2/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
It's very simple, do not buy these HDDs.I bought mine 2/9/11.. Started hearing the "click of death" roughly 6 months ago.Yesterday, the drive died..Also,These drives do not have the normal Seagate warranty, of 5 years.These only have a 2 year warranty.DO not waste your time or your money with these drives.
Фотон-0FQCT
04.06.2012
8/10
Оценка пользователя
Хорошо
I had ordered the unit but I forget why now and decided I did not need it, but the probable cost of sending it back would have been so great since I got such a good deal on the price I gave it to someone else, so far knock on wood I am not aware of any issues, which I am pretty sure I would have heard since I live in the same house.
ИнфраГость-0FVWP
17.11.2009
6/10
Оценка пользователя
Плохо
Okay I used to be a Seagate fanatic since I've used their drives for years and never once had to RMA one. I even got an old 15GB cheetah scsi drive that still works from like 2001! But this drive I don't know where Seagate quality control was when they made this one? I've had this drive a year and I still don't trust it and expect it to fail any day now that's how bad Seagate has fallen in my eyes. I mean it's not just the firmware fiasco it's my firsthand experience with this drive. After a couple of months it started running really slow and I would get these weird pauses playing back video or anything intensive on the drive. Never experienced anything like it before. Well the firmware update seemed to have fixed that. But soon after that I started getting strange noises from the drive so of course I ran seagate diagnostic tools to make sure it wasn't dying but it insisted the drive was good so that left me with no alternative but to complete format the drive and start over. That seems to have gotten rid of the noisy seeking of the drive for a while at least because now it's back! I was going to run seagate tools again but what do you know their software isn't compatible with Windows 7! so it looks like I'll have to find my bootable seagate diagnostic tools disc and see if I have to RMA the drive this time before the warranty runs out on it and before I lose my data! I'm just waiting now to find a reliable 2TB drive now since I also bought a Western Digital 2TB thinking they would be more reliable but no that one actually died already and I had to RMA it so if anyone knows of anyone that makes a reliable drive these days please let the rest of us know!Update: Okay I don't know if it's just a problem with the way this larger Seagate drives seek information on their larger drives but once again I got rid of the loud and random clicking noises by moving some of the data off this drive. It seems once you get near full capacity on this drive it starts to have problems finding data. Unfortunately, Seagate diagnostic tools says there is nothing wrong with drive and Windows can't find any bad sectors on it so it looks like I will have to put up with this noise longer until I get a replacement drive. After searching other websites this drive being noiser than a first-gen raptor drive seems to be common so maybe it's not that strange. What I do know though is that I also have the 1.5TB Seagate external usb/esata version and that one is pretty quiet and has't given me any problems. Also, the 2TB WD drive I have is pretty quiet and doesn't get noisy either. Still like I said I don't trust this drive since in my experience the only time I've ever had a drive get that noisy especially with clicking sounds is right before it died!My recommendation at this time would be to avoid larger capacity drive no matter what company makes them at this time unless you really need one since all the kinks don't seem to be worked out like the drives that have been around for a while.Update2: Okay I guess my instincts were right on and this drive finally died without warning. Did not even last a year. The way it died was most unusual too since I've never seen this happen with any of my harddrives before. It started doing it's noisy clicking and one day I turned on my computer and it was recognized as a ST-Ml3fqbl and not a ST31500341AS anymore. From what I could google this means the heads on the drive went bad :( Anyways, only good thing is that I can now RMA this and hopefully get a better replacement drive.
Спектроник-8GCGO
14.07.2012
2/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
I bought this replacement hard drive and am having to replace already- less than two years after purchase. Would not recommend anyone to buy this as it is not worth any price.
Вектрон-9QVMS
20.07.2012
2/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
I had this drive OEM Installed in my Dell XPS (1TB Seagate Barracuda 7200.12) and it failed in less than a month. So much for reliability.
Лунатик-4ABPA
11.12.2010
4/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
First of all: It is funny to me when people say that a good hard drive lasts 3-5 years. No, a good hard drive lasts 7-10 years. The fact that so many of these have problems is worrisome, but the the ones that do work are great.I bought one of these from a different etailer and decided to buy another for a low price here on Amazon (price has been jacked up since). I returned it because it failed. It is important to mention how Amazon packages this product. Amazon does a TERRIBLE job packaging these things. It is literally just sitting in a cardboard box. Other places like new egg do a much better job. Amazon also has terrible customer service. I wanted a replacement rather than a refund. My hard ST3500418AS bare drive had a different ASIN number so the customer service lady had a hissy fit about replacing it when I am sure the only difference is the firmware revision. That is a big FAIL on Amazon's part for having employees that know nothing about what they are selling. I opted it buy it from new egg for $5 more. They know their stuff and never gave me any problems. I'm definitely not coming back to Amazon for this type of product for a long time.The product itself worked for a few hours when all of a sudden I heard the hard "accessing" data non-stop. It didn't stop. I left my computer on over night and it still was going in the morning. The hard drive was busy doing something so intense that it took me literally an hour to boot into Windows 7. After running some hard drive diagnostic utilities on the drive, it turns out its built-in test was reallocating bad sectors. By the time I removed the drive from my computer there were 75 bad sectors!!!!! This number was still rising, as the hard drive continues to constantly be reallocating data. Most people RMA with a couple of bad sectors on a new hard drive. My other hard drive in the case that is 3 years old (a SAMSUNG T166) hard drive has 0 bad sectors.In short: Amazon - terrible packaging, worse customer service, sending this back for a refund. Oh yeah, they jacked up the price.Bought this same hard drive again from new egg where I got my first one.
Кронос-0JUYN
08.07.2012
2/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
Bought 4 drives from this seller. Two drives failed within the first weeks of use. I'll be replacing all of these drives as soon as I can.
Астрономад-4ARAO
30.01.2012
2/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
I bought six of these drives in July of 2009, and by December of 2011, three of them have failed. I tried updating the firmware following the instructions from Seagate's website, and they all either updated successfully, or didn't need updating (meaning all three failed drives have up-to-date firmware), and then tried running diagnostic on them again, and all three still failed.I will never buy Seagate again if I could help it. 50% failure rate is just unacceptable. Maybe I had a bad batch, but I have never encountered anything like this in 13 years of building my own computers, and it was very disappointing.
Вояджер-4AHMZ
26.01.2012
2/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
I worked fine for a week, but after that the drive would constantly make noises even if nothing's happening. If you tried to do anything, the drive would freak out and freeze. For example: When I play starcraft, it would all of the sudden start making a lot of noise, and the game would freeze for 10-20 seconds. It pretty much made my computer unusable. So every program you tried to run, it would lag and freeze. Please avoid this product even if it was recommended by tonymacx86 for a hackintosh. I built it perfectly right, but the only problem is the hard drive. It's a real buzz kill.
Астероид-6IFSM
07.02.2012
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
What else is there to say, it's a 7200 rpm drive that's still going strong 2 years, 7 months later without skipping a beat. It's now the data drive in combination with my new SSD Mushkin 120GB Chronos Deluxe which I couldn't be happier with. But I needed to give this Seagate its due respect for serving me well.I have no clue what I paid for it all these years later, but I don't recall it being all that expensive at the time.
ИнфраГость-8EGSN
18.02.2012
8/10
Оценка пользователя
Хорошо
With the floods and the shortages in the thailand hard drives are not cheap right now.I still needed one so I bought this at full price....... Whatever.Pros: 1tb of memory.... quiet nice to have as a back upCons: Paid full price.
Вектрон-6VHRP
29.11.2011
2/10
Оценка пользователя
Ужасно
My Seagate Lemon came in a HPE-250f from HP with a Core i7 package. It lasted about a month....just long enough to get all my data & programs loaded into the "Seagate Trap". After the usual 2 hour long back and forth with the HP Rep. from some other world, he agreed to send another drive....which was a Hitachi brand. Now a year later, I'm faced with the same dilema, but this time I was smart enough to have an external HD backup drive.
Лунатик-1DRYT
27.02.2012
10/10
Оценка пользователя
Великолепно
Delivered as promised! Seems to be working fine - replaced old hard drive on Server for our company - no problems so far!
Показаны отзывы 1-24 из 235.
|
Жесткий диск Seagate ST3160318AS 160Gb SATAII 3,5" HDD | Яндекс Маркет | 2 915 ₽ | Посмотреть |
График изменения цены Seagate Barracuda 160 ГБ ST3160318AS
Характеристи Seagate Barracuda 160 ГБ ST3160318AS
Информация о характеристиках носит справочный характер.
Перед покупкой уточняйте характеристики и комплектацию товара у продавца
Похожие товары с лучшей оценкой
Wizemart © 2026.
Рекомендательная система по умному выбору товаров по отзывам и рейтингам
