Отзывы о Акустическая Система Edifier S351DB
378 отзывов пользователей о Edifier S351DB
Пользовались
Edifier S351DB?
Поделитесь своим опытом и помогите другим сделать правильный выбор
I expected that these speakers would be ok for that purpose once in a while.
Boy was I surprised! I found that listening to Mozart's clarinet concert I was filled with Man's desiring, and a new appreciation for life due to the clarity of low frequency response I did not expect from 4" bass drivers!
Needless to say I am very pleased with this purchase and highly recommend these speakers for people who enjoy similar pursuits.
- Performance/Price
- Aesthetics
- Loud Volume
- Handling of Singular Tones
- Bass+Treble Adjustment
Cons:
- Lack of Low-End Bass
- Noisy Soundstage
- Bluetooth Always On
This speaker set aims to please from the get-go. From the unboxing to the first glimpse of the gorgeous faux-walnut to the ease of setup, the R1700bt is flawless in those regards. Volume levels went from whisper quiet to neighbour-waking loud, so no complaints there either. However, that was where the fun ended as some odd frequency response could be heard when different tracks were played. After about a 5-hour burn in, the sound signature settled down enough for an audition. For the remainder of this review, I will focus on my experience with the sound quality as I don't care much about other factors such as aesthetics or packaging when I purchase speakers.
First thing I noticed was the very sibilant and bright highs and vocals. The closest thing that I've heard to this is the virtual surround effect that some DACs offer. It's not an unpleasant effect when used in moderation and I think Edifier did a great job here. Vocal tracks were stunning for a <$200 speaker set. For pure vocals, the R1700bt beat every other computer speaker I've ever owned/auditioned: Edifier E3200, Simple Audio Listen, Fluance Fi30, Logitech Z533, and Tivoli Model Two. Secondly, the volume went much higher than I would likely ever play my music even in a largish 60ft2 room. The last thing about the R1700bt that put a smile on my face was the openness of the sound when tuned to -2 Treble/-4 Bass. There was very little box-like boominess, which is just the way I like it. It allowed the music to really be turned up without distortion.
However, after noting those strengths of the speakers, I also noticed several glaring weaknesses that no other review mentioned (even so-called professional reviews online). The first and most obvious is the complete lack of low-end bass; by which I mean <60hz. To challenge any of those aforementioned reviewers, I ask for them to please simply play "The Imperial March" from the ubiquitous Star Wars series. When I read all those reviews that stated "very nice", "strong", "full" bass, I expected the bass to at least beat the Tivoli Model Two 2.0 system that employs only single 3" drivers. But after just the first 30 seconds of "The Imperial March", I realized either all those reviewers didn't listen to any orchestral music with large drums or my speaker set is broken. "The Imperial March" became "The Imperial Walk" with barely any of the deep bass making its way to my ears. Much MUCH worse than my Model Two with their 3" drivers.
The second significant flaw that those "professional" reviewers failed to mention was the utter mess of the soundstage. Both the Tivoli and Fluance Fi30 handily beat the Edifier R1700bt when it came to highlighting the melody/focal point of the muscial score and separating the different harmonic parts into their individual strands. What actually came out from the R1700bt when compared to those speakers sounded more akin to a 2D painting with a cacophony of sound all intermixed and unrelated to each other. After some more careful listening, I believe this is in part due to the R1700bt having a flatter response curve than the Tivoli or Fluance and thus giving each instrument/vocal more of an equal representation. Whether this is good or bad is subjective: for me, I want to enjoy my music and not be distracted with overly harsh cymbals or annoying sizzles and pops from the accompaniment. Nonetheless, the result is a soundstage that is unable to "place" each instrument/vocal on the stage at all; everything comes out as one unit.
Before I conclude this review, I feel the need to emphasize that I DO like these speakers even with most of my review devoted to pointing out flaws. Hence the 4 star rating. However, it is even MORE important to add "for the price" to this conclusion. These are great speakers for the price, which I feel is what most reviews gloss over. No, the sound is NOT "golden", "perfect", or even close to "joyous" on an absolute value. It is merely wonderful for the lack of better competition. I know what good sound sounds like: B&W 802 hooked up to Moon NEO DAC and custom tube amp serves as my reference. Of course I don't expect a $200 bookshelf speaker set to come even remotely close to that setup. But for me to state that the R1700bt has solid bass, full mids, and clear/crisp highs would be a blatant lie. Kudos if you have reached this point of this review! My parting words for you will be to not expect much better sound that what this speaker set costs; there is no miracle yet.
have been spoilt by my earlier logitech setup (miss the subwoofer and low thundering sound). For the purpose I bought them (listening to music), they do justice and go beyond. Love them. Should you buy them? My Answer - Hell yeah!
Date : 10th November 2019
I have been listening them for more than 1.5 years. The sound quality is still fantastic and no problem at all. Most people who come home, and if I like them enough, I give them a demo of these incredible set of speakers and all I get in return is mesmerised faces! Thank you Edifier for making this possible.
I'll keep updating this review.
for 2 to 3 hours a day if possible now if you are planning to buy this then i can tell you go for it but still ifeel my responsibility to tell who should
buy them and who should not .
pros.
1.its very compatible and fits on your bookshelf easly it can be easly put on a computer table.
2.this looks great ,i mean the design is great and the wooden touch add gems to the overall look,just watching them you will love them.hatts off edifier.
3.all the cables and the blue tooth works flawless iconnect it to my tv and sounds dam good for my hd channel one i noted there is a small ticle sound in some channels but thats ok as to get great
output you need great input ,but the sound goes after some time and for some channels its not
even there overall i enjoy watching movies itt just enhancces the sound try watching ice age 4 it just gave me chills at some points,i play ericclapton songs from the bluetooth and sounds crisp clear i just dont have
words to express the awsm sound it produces.
4.i m not a sound director but i definetly know what good sound
and marshall at some sections they sound far better as i have heard them at my friends house,my friends feel jealous when they listen to my edifiers and i dont mind.
now
the cons
1.actually there are no cons if you ask me but if i have to say then it would be in some songs i have heard extra bass or trebble but i am good with that
as there are to knobs one for bass and one for treeble which is great again.
verdict.these speakers are not for out site use yes you can use for small get togather at your garden as i do and 62rms will blast off things but if you dont have much to do with the quality of music (i know you do)and
just want boom and shake the doors and windows of your neighbour the you are looking at the wrong place ,these speakers are made with one aim and that is quality sound so turn off
the light and relax on your bed with your partner enjoy your favourite song and dont focus on blasting others ear drum just
buy them dont give asecond thought....thanku edifiers for making such alovely speaker ,i am from india have a wonderful day.
Received different remote controller than what is shown in the pictures.
The only thing I'd have liked a bit different is an input select on the unit, and a reverse stero dip switch so the power outlet speaker position was more versatile. Don't like the remote reliance for the blue tooth either. But, the functionality and switches are what they are and anytime the speakers are pumping I couldn't care less about the remote or cabling. These sound FANTASTIC for the money.
I know the audiophile crowd knock this unit for the bass heavy neutral eq, and I can hear what they're saying. The resonance of the box does carry the lower Hz a bit, but the fidelity of the unit's envelope is still great with the bass knob turned down a touch. And inversely, when I want to listen to DnB/HipHop and let the bass rip it's perfect for such a moderatly powered set up.
Anything else I've tried in the price range in the computer desk category is definitely inferrior. If you're thinking of spending similar money on a Logitec set, skip'em. Get the Edifier. Logitch is fine with your mouse buisness.
Upon hooked them up, the difference in sound quality from the other speakers was instantly noticeable. I was playing 35-40 year old vinyl through the RCA connection and everything sounded so crisp and clear. The treble, bass and volume controls allow you to adjust the settings to your liking and the remote control allows you to switch between RCA connection and Bluetooth connection easily. If you really wanted to upset the neighbours with these speakers, you definitely could!
Overall, I would say that these speakers are incredible value for money. If you are expecting tons of bells and whistles, you might want to consider paying more for higher end speakers/ amp set up but for easy-to-use, strong performance and quality build, for under $200, I certainly have not found anything close to these bad boys! Definitely recommend!
The build of the speakers seems to be sturdy enough, and the cables ( both power and speaker ) provided are quite long and very thick.
The speakers are wonderful when placed correctly in medium/ large room.
Personally I am using them connected to the FiiO K5 via RCA cables, playing from a docked FiiO X3II. Works beautifully and sound is nice and clear. Treble and Bass are set neutral and for me the sound is perfect.
I have tested the Bluetooth capabilities as well playing music from an Android tablet and 2 different cellphones. No issues and connection is quick and painless. Sound is still good. You cannot connect multiple tablets/cellphones to them - only one. Once something is connected to it already, the speakers cannot be found when searching for them.
The remote comes in handy and while is not matching the finish and feel of the speakers, I am happy to have it. The speakers are literally set inside a bookshelf cabinet away from my computer and I do not have to get up every time to change the volume or switch between Line in / Bluetooth :). Lazy life, happy life :D.
With 2 separate speakers, stereo soundstage and separation is manageable with maintaing distance between speakers, which is missing in most of Bluetooth single piece speakers available now a days.
Added my first Edifier in my many good sounding speakers collection from Bose, Herman Kardon, Yamaha, Polk Audio and Amazon Eco & Eco dot.
While choosing this speaker, keep in mind that this system is using 4 inch driver with tweeter. Which can not be compared with other systems sound reproduction level with larger drivers - 6 inch / 8 inch. Having 4 inch driver, sound reproduction and frequency response is good and giving smooth listening experience.
Quick delivery in less than 10 hours from Amazon Delivery Services. Good Packaging, received product in great condition👍
What is Great - Clarity of sound is amazing. Vocals are warm and Crystal Clear. You will love the smoothness of the sound. Mids are perfetly balanced and highs are quite sharp. Bass is not over bearing but good enough. The same songs now sound so new. Love the quality of the sound. And the wooden panels give it a classy look.
What's not so great - I wish they were slightly more louder to completely immerse me with sound of the music. Grill could have been better and audio cables (apart from the thick cable to connect the two speakers) look cheap. And lastly, if you are looking for floor thumping bass, this is not for you. Bluetooth version is old .Why not BT5 ?
Edifier , please bring the big brother S2000 pro to India soon.
Ok, the battery drawer finally came out.
Was in backwards.
After a bunch more fiddling with Bluetooth, these are connected.
Sound is great.
Connecting through Bluetooth is easy and it hasn't dropped out at all like it does with another Bluetooth speaker I have after a few hours of play.
I’m sure $1000 speakers would sound better, but for $179 these are a steal! They really do sound pretty good. I’d be curious to hear the next level up that Edifier offers for $100 more.
I recommend these speakers.
At first they sounded very good, yet too quiet to be worth the money.
Then, with that flick of the line switch everything came roaring to life! Wow! Clear, crisp sound, nice clean highs with low, undistorted bass.
I haven't heard music sound so nice in a while! I'm sure that's partially due to listening to uncompressed sound on records, but these speakers really do it justice!
These are definitely worth the money!
one annoying thing about this speaker is a control, the Bluetooth and line-in option only appear on the remote control. if you lost or damage the remote control, the speakers are done.
I played a couple rock, jazz and classical songs on the speakers and enjoyed the separation and tonality... Played the opening scene of Star Trek and found the audio level to be quite immersive and not overpowering.
Higher volumes did distort a bit, but you mostly lost lower frequencies with the high end holding together fairly well..
Overall I would say that these speakers are very well priced for what you get. Plus with Bluetooth connectivity, it gives you much more freedom over the placement of the speakers as more and more devices are coming Bluetooth enabled.
Yes I would definitely recommend these to others! I'm very happy I did the research into these speakers, excellent purchase that should last me years to come!
My only gripe is that the remote is a little fiddly and there is no physical Line/Bluetooth button on the speaker unit itself. Don't lose that remote!
The bluetooth function makes them incredibly convenient for Spotify, audiobook, or podcast listening. But the bluetooth function is double edged sword because, unless I missed something (completely possible, probably the case), the only way to pair the bluetooth is with the remote that comes in tandem with the speakers. Plastic, thin, small, jet black = easy to lose and without it pairing new devices may prove tough.
Also, on the remote, black speakers, and grey buttons? Just do with black with white buttons so it's easy to see in most light levels.
Criticisms seems to be nit-picking and all the pros certainly out-weigh the few cons. Will recommend.
I am a sound engineer getting close to 50 years now and I enjoy all genre music around the globe in any language. The only genre I don't like is, heavy metal rock with distorted tones. I use this in my bedroom. The sound is rich and powerful.
This Edifier R1700BT gives a pleasant listening pleasure to all kind of music.
Frequency is well balanced so you can tweak to exact taste for your ears.
Every tone of the instrument is clean and so natural sounding. So you feel so fresh and live.
I had also gone through many reviews before choosing this. Finally ended with this and enjoying.
Finally it is a Pleasure at affordable Price
Tiny remote (size of an open book of matches) is required to switch inputs which is a bit of a pain. Don't lose it!
UPDATE: If you push in and hold the volume button, it will switch inputs.
Some perks: the bass and treble knobs are very sensitive and it was easy to balance them to my liking. Also, the input cables they come with seem to be on par with monoprice quality, nothing special but they work and don;'t seem flimsy. Lastly, the fade in and volume increase is very nice when you don't realize the volume is cranked and you start a track.
Positives
- Fills a big room with very decent volume and sound quality
- Okay design
- Can be used with TV. Notice the sound difference by switching between TV speakers and these speakers. You wont like the TV sound much when you switch to these
Negatives
- No such negatives if bought be someone who knows what he or she is buying
- Do not buy if you want heavy base. Buy a Logitech Z-625 instead. Which is good for laptop/desktop pairing. Has very neat sound and heavy base.
PS: Get hold of Klipsch 2.1 Promedia if possible which is currently available at much higher cost. Ideal cost for Klipsch is between 10k - 15k. But the speakers are unbeatable. I own one and have never had issues with sound. Can bring down a house
Besides that, they still sound very good, even at very high volumes, and DANG they can get loud for their size.
Now, the remote control, it's not the greatest. It's very slow to respond, and just feels so.. flimsy. And the Bluetooth seems aggressive. my girlfriend had connected to it when we were testing them out upon unboxing. Later, while I was using them through the hardwire input, she was off having a shower, listening to music through her phone connected to another bluetooth speaker on the bathroom counter. Out of nowhere, with neither of us interacting with it, the Edifier speakers re-initialized connection. So that was bothersome.
All in all, they're gorgeous and sound VERY good. Just maaybe not studio quality good, but I'm still just a noob.
However, please do not compare it with speakers costing more than 40k a pair which obviously is not a correct comparison.
These are best for the budding audiophile who wishes to develop a taste for the nuances while hearing instrumental, Soft Indian, Classical etc.
Do not use it for a party as it will not move the floor.
I am running it on my MAC through TIDAL. Getting high quality Indian music on the net is a challenge.Overall I am extremely satisfied with the quality of sound and the looks.
Ultimately I decided to get these - let me break down my experience.
I've always had 5.1 systems, and was coming from a 2.1 - so I was really on the fence if I needed the subwoofer for such a small room. I love the bass, but honestly, my neighbour downstairs probably doesn't, so I started to gravitate towards these. I could've bought the 1850 which also has a sub out, but again, probably in the near future, this wouldn't matter.
In the end of the day, I got these, and for all my uses (Videogame, Movies and Music) This has been so far one of the best sounds I've had. I'm no audiophile, but I do like my sound clean! For the money, this is by far your best bet. I also don't miss my subwoofer from the previous setup, these do a decent job on a nice balanced bass.
Anyway I didn't feel that good about it so I returned the product.
But they actually sounded half decent. Like, surprisingly so. And they look pretty good too.
I went and looked up a bunch of reviews post-purchase, and it turns out that's not an uncommon reaction. Many reviewers are surprised at how not-awful these speakers are and how far they punch above their class. (See, e.g., "Z Reviews"'s video "Edifier // Dayton // Plugable // Rockville _(Z Reviews)_ AFFORDABLE SPEAKER BLOWOUT!!".)
This is a great price point to buy at -- good value for the money. Looks like you're not going to get a lot better quality unless you spend a lot more money, and anything less is going to be a big compromise.
Yes, there are better speakers. Any audiophile can give you a half dozen options for a mere 4x the price and you'll only need a DAC and an amplifier and... Or there's these. They're cheap, and they're good enough for us mere mortals.
1. The speakers have very sweet and warm sound which is not harsh to ears.
2. I was using Bose speakers (companion20). Though there was more clarity in them but issue was harsh sound in rock and metal songs due to absence of separate drivers for highs and mids. No doubt that there quality was superb but what you hear was not accurate in them. These edifiers are giving very accurate audio and best part is that they are a treat to the ears.
3. Though there is some muddiness in sound but I don't think that any speaker comes without flaws and most important thing I need to tell is that speakers are not just about clarity but things like soundstage, accurate audio, sweetness and how long can you listen to them. Edifiers R1700bt passes these tests.
4. there are better speakers available in the market but they cost a fortune. So, they are value for money.
+ Aesthetics: They look fantastic. I love the wood finish, and they're not to big.
+ Installation: Once I plugged in the cable into the correct port in my motherboard, and then tweaked the Sonic Sound Suite software they worked immediately and with no problems or fuss.
+ Sound Quality: Excellent. Considering the price and the 2 speaker range as opposed to 5.1 or 7.1 setups, I was very impressed with these. No regrets!
Bad:
- None. I'm completely satisfied with these speakers.
Perfect treble and thumping bass. Mids could have been a bit better. The design is flawless and build is solid. The bass ports are front firing allowing them to be placed close to the walls. Stereo separation is beautiful.
If your focus is on Bass and Booms, this is not for you. There are much cheaper alternatives in the market for that.
This is for balanced and refined music. Go for it eyes closed if you are a classics/ rock/ metal/ blues lover.
Definitely recommend !





