Отзывы о Жесткий диск Western Digital 1.5 ТБ WD15EADS

123 отзывов пользователей o Western Digital 1.5 ТБ WD15EADS

Пользовались Western Digital 1.5 ТБ WD15EADS?
Поделитесь своим опытом и помогите другим сделать правильный выбор

Оставить свой отзыв

Скроменый эксперт

30.01.2010

10/10

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

I have been a computer tech for over 30 years, and have always used and recommended Western Digital drives to others. And this particular drive would be no exception. The packaging is well-designed, protecting the drive in a manner similar to that of their retail packaging...antistatic bags, and the plastic end caps to hold the drive in the center of the interior space. These ARE OEM drives, so there is no other items included. Be sure to have SATA data and power cable adapters on hand for quick installation. These drives were purchased for use in my NAS RAID box. I had been considering purchase of 4 1TB drives, but these came along, and I got the same capacity with one less physical drive. The SATA controller I have running the RAID array operates at only SATA I speed, so you need to be sure to set the jumper on the option block to run the drive at this speed. Note that there are NO jumpers on the drive as shipped, so be sure you have some of them on hand as well, if you need to set it to run at SATA I mode. Overall, these are an excellent drive for the price. Power savings as well as cost savings. Even though only a 1 year warranty, I have had only a few WD drives fail on me in the dozens I have owned (many of which were running 24/7), and then only after a period of at least 5 to 6 years. A great deal...don't pass it up!

Отзыв предоставлен

Скроменый эксперт

08.01.2010

8/10

Оценка пользователя

Хорошо

Due to poor packing of these drives (Boxes where not really secure in larger box, drives were not packed with foam or plastic retainer, subjected to shock of being bounced around) I have no idea if MTBF has been significantly reduced. My gut feeling is yes, it has. But until the drives fail, I will not know. I expect the lifetime of the drives to be about 3 yrs.Some background on me. I have been doing work in the IT field for almost 20yrs now. This is the worst packaging of Hard Drives I have seen. Although the pictures of where Amazon sent the drives in a slim envelope/card board was pretty scary. I hope to update this post around the 90 day mark to see if either drive has failed.1/8/2010 - Later in the afternoon/early evening.After talking to others in our IT department, it seems that this style of product packaging is becoming more prevalent and I should really wait the 90 days before passing judgement. "Yes it is new style packaging, yes it looks flimsy. No, it really is not." was the message I got. Okay, my intestinal fortitude is still not where I would like it, but I am willing to give it a go. If I pass the 30 day mark without drive failure, I will mark up a star. If I pass the 90 day mark without a drive failure, I will give a whole hearted endorsement.2/2/2010 - Closing in on the 30 day mark and no failures. Marked up a star. The packaging still forces me to do a gut check.

Отзыв предоставлен

Скроменый эксперт

27.10.2010

4/10

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

I am a Western Digital fan and most of my new drives are WD Caviar Green. They are quiet and efficient, although not the fastest. Unfortunately this 15EADS failed in service after 63 days of work time. I have checked it using WD's WinDlg.exe program and it failed both tests showing multiple problems. I am building my own computers for many years now and newer had hard drive failure before!

Отзыв предоставлен

Скроменый эксперт

11.06.2010

4/10

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

Ok, picked up a couple of these drives at Christmas. One is a 64Mb Cache and the other is 32Mb Cache. The drives are super quiet, and run nice and cool. These drives would be the perfect choice for the average user that doesn't care about speed to load programs or pictures, videos etc.DO NOT use these drives in a server! Especially Windows Home Server unless you are only storing important documents. These drives are NOT fast enough to stream video from a WHS Server. Tried it and didn't work. Glitchy choppy video every time server drive balancing service runs, which is around every hour or so.Streaming from a standard home computer works fine but can be dicey if you are streaming HD.

Отзыв предоставлен

Скроменый эксперт

11.01.2010

4/10

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

I have 5 hdd in my computer, and they have all ended up being WD because the others have failed after a couple years. I decided to consolidate a couple into one larger drive (this one), Music and ISO files. I should not have gone for the 'green drive' because while it still works, it barely works. music files take several seconds to start playing with all my music players, opening folders on this HD is slow in both linux and windows. Initially the hd would randomly not appear in POST or BIOS, but after many hours of messing around I switched sata ports on the [3 month old] motherboard to get it to work. Other sata drives dont have issues with that port so im thinking its still the hd even though it shows up in BIOS consistently now. This is the first 'green' drive ive gotten from wd so maybe the underperformance is by design. Since ive now had disks from every major manufacturer fail on me, im grudgingly going back to higher performance wd drives. I would advise against green drives for the moment, a couple watts isnt worth this crap.

Отзыв предоставлен

Скроменый эксперт

07.03.2010

10/10

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

I purchased three of these drives for placement in my HP EX495 1.5TB Mediasmart Home Server ( Black) a little over a month ago. So far they are running just great. These drives are very quiet. I have the server in my basement and when I am downstairs working, I cannot even tell the server is running except for the lights on the front of it. The Caviar Green drives run 10 to 15 degrees cooler than the Seagate Barracuda 7200.11 1.5 TB SATA 32 MB Cache Bulk/OEM Hard Drive ST31500341AS that came with the unit, even when backing up data. They idle at about 80 degrees and max out at 95 degrees. I have seen the Seagate as high as 110 degrees. Yes they are only 5400rpm compared to the Seagate, but for a server that is just backing up the computers in the house and streaming music & video they are more than adequate.

Отзыв предоставлен

Скроменый эксперт

01.02.2010

10/10

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

I bought this HD becuase I was running out of space on stock HD. I decided to go with WD becuase after two of my Seagate HD crashed on me, I didn't really trust them anymore. However, what most people need to know is that this product is an OEM meaning that these are primarily shipped to buyers like Dell and HP who then use them in there computers when you oder them, so this means that they will not come with any screws or wire hareness or addapters. You will need to buy your own. And becuase it is an OEM again, you won't be getting what you think with the packaging. It's very simple, just the HD no manuel, but it's pretty easy to put into you computer if you know what it is you're doing. So once, again to all the people who gave it bad rating, it's an OEM product so they will only sent you the HD. If you want you can buy a the more expensive model for the packaging and wires and harnesses.

Отзыв предоставлен

Скроменый эксперт

23.05.2010

2/10

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

This is the worst hard drive ever. I've literally installed windows 7 on this thing 3-4 times a day for the past 5 days. The amount of data corruption is unbelievable. It'll be running fine one minute, then you install an update or new software and you can't reboot. If you have corruption you're lucky because sometimes your computer won't even recognize the existence of this drive. Reformatting doesn't help at all. BTW you can only access 1.36 TB of the drive.

Отзыв предоставлен

Скроменый эксперт

23.02.2010

2/10

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

"Amazon Has Certified That This Packaging Is Frustration-Free"-- My frustration started with the package and escalated both when I opened it and when I attempted to use the drive. It came in the anti-static standard bag with an invoice wrapped around it, that's it, nothing else. No protective bubbles, no padding, just a box and a drive. When I plugged it in all I heard was clicking, no spinning, it was the faint sound of a DOA drive. Was unable to partition it, view it in disk manager, or anything. Very disappointing. Not blaming this on the drive either, likely poor packaging is the reason for failure. Even if the drive had worked, I'd of given it a one simply due to the poor decision of how to package this sensitive electronic equipment.

Отзыв предоставлен

Скроменый эксперт

30.04.2010

10/10

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

I've had the WD7500AADS for about a month now, installed in an Icy Dock external firewire/USB enclosure. The drive serves as the Time Machine backup of my office computer, so it performs automatic backups multiple times per day. So far, it is working flawlessly. It replaces a 500GB Seagate 7200.11 drive, and it is so much quieter and cooler than the Seagate that I can hardly believe it. Really an excellent drive, and one to get if you're concerned about the block size issue on the newer Caviar Green EARS drives.

Отзыв предоставлен

Скроменый эксперт

29.04.2010

10/10

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

I have owned several brands of hard drive int he past including Maxtor, Seagate, Western Digital and Hitachi. The only ones I have never had a problem with are Western Digital and for the last five years that is the only hard drives I have used in all my PCs. They are reliable, offer good performance and are reasonably priced. This one has gone into the media player to play my DVD collection from the hard disk. Highly recommend Western Digital brand hard disks.

Отзыв предоставлен

Скроменый эксперт

03.12.2009

10/10

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

As to the comments of poor packaging, my drive arrive today packaged in a large over-pack box with crushed brown paper surrounding a smaller inner box. The inner box was custom fitted for the drive with much room around the drive and with fitted inner restraints to keep the drive in position in the inner box. The drive was encased in the usual anti-static plastic envelope. If your drive is packaged as mine was you should have no worries.Note: If your package is delivered to your doorstep and has sat out in the cold for a while (as mine had), the drive also will, of course, be cold. So, BEFORE YOU OPEN THE ANTI-STATIC BAG, allow the drive to come to room temperature. Otherwise you should expect moisture to condense on the drive and even though it is a sealed drive unit, it's still better to allow everything to stabilize to room temp and not take a chance with moisture condensing on it. Just give it an hour or two and it should be fine.

Отзыв предоставлен

Скроменый эксперт

21.01.2010

2/10

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

I never thought I'd write a review about the packaging, but this was really really a poor packing job. The reviews that say that the packaging has been fixed no longer seems to be true. The bare drive arrived loose in a box with no cushion and was left on my doorstep in the rain. Amazon really needs to reexamine how it packages fragile tech components such as this and its delivery policies with its shippers.I can't believe that a company like Amazon can ship drives like this so haphazardly. I have my fingers crossed that this drive will actually last and not fail because of the poor shipping policies of Amazon. As a prime member, I expect some thought and care to ensuring a safe delivery. Amazon needs to remedy this situation QUICKLY and PUBLICLY.

Отзыв предоставлен

Скроменый эксперт

23.03.2010

10/10

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

I purchased this HD because I was running out of storage capacity for my digital videos. I have some experience putting together computers, so this was a rather simple plug & play experience. Since buying it I have had no problems at all, so I couldn't really comment on service/support as it wasn't needed. Although the item shipped quickly and arrived undamaged, I was a little upset at the lack of packing materials used to protect such a sensitive item.

Отзыв предоставлен

Скроменый эксперт

08.12.2009

10/10

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

This is an excellent hard drive with a vast amount of space to store pictures and videos. The SATA connections were easy to make and the drive was very easy to install in my external eSATA enclosure. Even though it's a "green" drive and spins slower than other drives, I have not noticed that it's slow to respond and for external data storage, it provides an ideal solution to my storage needs.This drive was provided from a supplier, not shipped by Amazon.com and the packaging of this drive by the outside supplier was excellent. They properly surrounded the drive on all six sides with bubble wrap in the packing box. Amazon.com needs to take some lessons from this supplier in how to properly package a hard drive.It's a great drive, excellent deal, I definitely would deal with this supplier again.

Отзыв предоставлен

Скроменый эксперт

19.01.2010

10/10

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Until now I've been buying the WD Caviar Green 750GB version of this drive. Now this drive is the price-point sweet spot. I have 2 750GB and one 1.5TB drive in my Windows Home Server machine. It is installed hooked up to a SATA PCI card. WHS recognized the drive right away and within a few minutes it was up and running. The drive runs cool and quiet as advertised. I've had one drive running for over a year, another one for six months and this one for about 1 month. My WHS machine is up 24/7 and serves media as well as backing up all the PCs/laptops in the house. If I need another drive soon this will be the one I get.So far so good knock on wood.

Отзыв предоставлен

Скроменый эксперт

13.01.2010

2/10

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

I have never had issues like this in the past with western digital drives. I have 4 raptor drives and wanted one of these for media storage and backup. It was a big mistake. My first drive was Dead on Arrival. I got it RMA'd and got the replacement. The replacement worked but I was seeing 1MB/sec writes speeds with the drive. It took me about 20 hours to transfer 136GB of data from one internal drive to this one. A few days later windows is reporting this drive as about to fail and that I should backup immediately. I assume this is the SMART technology. I'm shipping this unit back and getting a 1MB Black (not green) drive so I can hopefully have some better luck.

Отзыв предоставлен

Скроменый эксперт

04.12.2009

10/10

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

In the context that I'm using it, this is a perfect drive. I now have five of these sitting in a home-built server running Ubuntu 9.04, all in a software (mdadm) RAID array with lvm across the top for partitioning/volume management, and I couldn't be happier. They're low power, which perfectly accents my 24/7 online headless server, and have yet to cause any issues whatsoever. I have a decently cooled case--an Antec 300--and they stay reasonably cool, averaging about 33 degrees Celsius. I've also enabled TLER on each of the drives using the easily obtainable Western Digital WDTLER utility so as to avoid any potential issues with use in a RAID array; this is a feature you pay big bucks for in an "enterprise" level drive.A great performer, and perfect for a home server. Highly recommended.

Отзыв предоставлен

Скроменый эксперт

18.02.2010

2/10

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

REJECT all packages lacking PADDING ON ALL SIX BOX SURFACES meeting or exceeding UPS standards. I have ZERO confidence in electronics received in any other condition. I continue to exchange the item until amazon can be bothered to correctly package it. I have recently started a habit of calling customer service prior to an order, placing the order, and giving the rep the order number to ENSURE the item is PROPERLY packed in the box.Amazon is NO DEAL WHATSOEVER when shipping practices endanger reliability/longevity of merchandise.

Отзыв предоставлен

Скроменый эксперт

26.04.2010

10/10

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

So far, I've filled it up to about 2/3rds it's capacity with a customer's data...no problems after several days of use. It's impressively quiet. I work with a lot of hard drives (I'm an in-home PC tech) so I know how loud HDDs usually are...and I was impressed by this one.

Отзыв предоставлен

Скроменый эксперт

01.02.2010

6/10

Оценка пользователя

Плохо

This drive is a good choice if you need just single disk operation. It is not a good choice if you need it to be part of a RAID set as the latest revisions removed support for TLER. The WD15EADS previously supported TLER, making it a good choice for a low cost RAID drive but WD wants you to purchase their "RAID-capable" RE2 drives for a significantly higher cost instead so they removed TLER support. The Samsung HD154UI does support TLER (technically CCTL, Samsung's version of TLER) so anyone who is interested in RAID should look at that drive instead.

Отзыв предоставлен

Скроменый эксперт

05.12.2009

8/10

Оценка пользователя

Хорошо

The WD 1.5TB Green drive seems to be working fine.I just hope down the line, it doesn't fail because of the packaging during shipping. It was packaged like a pin ball in a box; to make matters worse, our mailman dropped it over a 5ft fence while we were not home. Since it is "Bulk/OEM" packaging, there is nothing but a thin layer of antistatic film covering it. Amazon's standard plastic air bags won't protect this product. A simple bubble wrap that costs what-a few pennies-would work a lot better, protect the hard drive from hard impacts, and save $ for amazon from future returns due to failed harddrives. Heck, even the wrapping they used to put books in would've been nice. That's why I rated only 4 stars; otherwise, it would've been 5 stars.

Отзыв предоставлен

Скроменый эксперт

02.04.2010

2/10

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

Purchased 2 of these drives to serve in a RAID array in July, 2009. In October, both failed nearly simultaneously. Received warranty replacements from Western Digital (they charged my credit card for shipping). Now one of the drives has failed again (March, 2010). With this kind of reliability, I would look elsewhere.

Отзыв предоставлен

Скроменый эксперт

16.01.2010

8/10

Оценка пользователя

Хорошо

My only current issue with this product is the manner in which it was shipped by Amazon. I was shocked by the lack of protection provided to this order. It's a hard drive, and it's just put in a box with the anti-static bag. No bubble wrap? Peanuts? The shipping is discounted, I know, but certain items deserve a little bit more than corrugated cardboard. Hopefully it received minimal shock during shipment, which the box attests to (unlike my other delivery from Amazon). I'm not terribly worried, since most damage is done while they run if jostled, but come on.

Отзыв предоставлен

Показаны отзывы 49-72 из 123.

Отзывы о Жесткий диск Western Digital 1.5 ТБ WD15EADS

123 отзывов пользователей o Western Digital 1.5 ТБ WD15EADS

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Хорошо

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Плохо

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Хорошо

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

Скроменый эксперт

Оценка пользователя

Хорошо

Похожие товары с лучшей оценкой

Это Вам тоже может быть интересно