Отзывы о Жесткий диск Seagate Barracuda 1 ТБ ST31000520AS

163 отзывов пользователей o Seagate Barracuda 1 ТБ ST31000520AS

Пользовались Seagate Barracuda 1 ТБ ST31000520AS?
Поделитесь своим опытом и помогите другим сделать правильный выбор

Оставить свой отзыв

КиберНаблюдатель-7WLES

23.04.2010

10/10

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

I have 6 2TB Seagate LP 5900 rpm drives in my readyNAS Pro, and so far so good.Four of them I bought about a year ago (Frys). Two of them I bought on a sale from Microcenter recently.Heat: I had a Hitachi 2TB 7200 rpm drive that was always 45 degrees when in operation. The Seagates were 39 degrees on the average.Noise: I could hear my Hitachi clicking and trashing all the way from my living room to my dining room. Not so with my Seagates. When the plates started to spin I could hear the Hitachi do all kinds of noises as well. This was true when the Hitachi was in the NAS and when it was in it's own usb enclosure. When I removed the Hitachi from the RAID (after it failed) and added more Seagates, the noise issue was gone.Reliability: My single Hitachi died, my 4 almost same age Seagates are cruising, now what are the chances of that happening...In my experience, the Seagates are cool and so my NAS doesn't have to spin the fans too much, making the whole system silent. They are also relatively inexpensive, and somewhat power efficient. I do not need the hard drive speed in my NAS. However, if you are a gamer and plan to install a hard drive in your custom gaming PC, I can understand if 5900 rpm 3Gbs 32M cache is not going to cut it, and may be better off looking for something else that properly exploits the features of your motherboard.I was worried about buying these drives back when I purchased them @ Frys given the problems that their previous 1.5TB line had. But so far these hard drives have not failed me.

оригинал отзыва

Пульсар-0BNXO

08.12.2010

4/10

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

The Good... I bought these on special during the cyberweek deals @$59.99 each which is a good price.The Bad... The reviews you read about the noise are not exaggerating. These are just about the noisiest drives on the market. I used them primarily as file server drives and all i hear is a loud whir and constant clicking - that's a bad product.The Ugly... I've used these for less than 2 days (in non-continuous use) and one drive has already failed. Suffice it to say I am returning both due to them being defective (most likely) or being damaged during shipping (somewhat likely).Oh Seagate what has happened to your hard drives?!Do yourself a favor spend a few more bucks and go Western Digital.1.5 stars just for storage space and price

оригинал отзыва

Астрономад-8HQEK

26.10.2010

2/10

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

1 month after purchasing an 1.5TB External Seagate hard drive with this disk installed inside, I could hear some thicks and weird noises from the drive and finally the malfunction. The drive stopped and then continued working and finally stopped completely! I extracted the disk and connected it into a internal SATA port and the same problem occured. I had 1TB filled with info. So I decided to purchase the same drive but in this case, only INTERNAL. I opened the box and installed it into my system. With a Thermaltake external SATA-USB docking station I could transfer info from the old 1.5TB seagate hd to the new 1.5TB hd. I have 3 weeks with the new drive and it began to make noises too!!! What kind of disk are these?I WON'T RECOMMEND THIS DRIVES TO YOU.If you want a better performance and quality, goto Western Digital. My external WD 500GB is 1 year old and is flawless,Daniel

оригинал отзыва

Квазар-8CCGG

01.12.2010

10/10

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

2TB on one spindle for $70! My first drive was 10MB for $800!The setup issue is in how to set up the partitioning to be 4KB-sector friendly on Windows XP. The Seagate DiscWizard (download only, this is a bare drive) refused to set up two partitions - insisted on setting up one partition to fill the entire drive. After some Googling I ended up using diskpar.exe to create the first partition at 64 sector offset.Packaging was just the OEM cardboard box and plastic supports for the bare drive. A little worrying but the drive set up fine.It came with firmware CC34 (production around 10110), CC35 is on the Seagate site but would not install for me. I emailed Seagate to ask about that.Now I hope for long life!

оригинал отзыва

Лунатик-6KVBG

26.02.2011

8/10

Оценка пользователя

Хорошо

I bought this drive as a replacement for one that kicked the bucket after a year of service. I use these drives in a DROBO and have had good luck so far, with the exception of the one that recently failed. If this one fails as well I will certainly have to find another vendor and re-think my rating. I want to claim they are great drives but that will depend on how long this one lasts.

оригинал отзыва

КиберНаблюдатель-5ZJHE

23.04.2011

10/10

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

I purchased 2 drives to run in my QNAP 419+ NAS system. They have been tunning for a months and are quiet and run cool. So far so good. I'll be purchasing more soon to expand the storage capacity.

оригинал отзыва

Плазмоид-3BIJD

23.01.2011

10/10

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

i have 8 of these drives in RAID 5 in my QNAP 859 pro+. so far they have been working flawlessly. QNAP has been running 24/7 for about a month. didnt perform any firmware updates on the drives. write times from an iMac to the QNAP over wired network averages about 70MB/sec according to istat pro running on the mac. haven't done any formal speed testing yet but when i do i will amend this review. will also amend this review if any of the drives fail.was happy with the frustration free packaging.

оригинал отзыва

Синтрон-1BSGR

20.10.2009

4/10

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

Basic specs: This is a 5900 RPM drive, rated at 95MB/s max transfer rate and <16ms access (per the product manual). The power consumption is 3.0W idle and an an amazing 19dBA/20dBA noise--per the specs.To be honest, I wasn't expecting much after having disappointing (atrocious?) performance from WDC's "green" drives. As far as performance, however, I was pleasantly surprised. This drive tops out at 120MB/s--way above spec. The AVERAGE is 95 MB/s. Also, I was expecting access times (including rotational latency) to be well above 20ms. However, here again, I was pleasantly surprised with 14.7ms--way above spec.OK, here's where I drop the bomb. I have no idea what kind of drugs Seagate was on when they came up with the acoustics. It is on their website, their datasheet, and the product manual. I have been impressed with past Seagate drives over their quietness, so I was really hoping this would be a very quiet drive at its rated 19dB which is even low for laptop drives. In fact, the low noise is the main reason I bought this. I didn't buy it for performance. I have SSDs and VelociRaptors for that. This is a media drive. And, the noise is obnoxious. This two-platter drive is louder than my 7200 RPM 4-platter Seagates. It is also louder than my VelociRaptors. The noise is also far worse than rated because it is a very high-pitched whine. About the closest I can think of is the old WDC Raptor 10K RPM drives.As a final note, my Watt-Meter measured about a 4W difference between plugged in and not. This is at the wall, so considering power supply efficiencies, 3W or so is believable which is very low power.In sum, this is a great drive for a file server that is far away in a closet somewhere. Its performance is good, and it is low power. Unfortunately, for a desktop or media center PC, the noise will give you a headache. There are better drives for those applications, like the older, quieter, 7200 RPM Seagates for starters. For any application where the drives sleep when not used, any power savings with this drive is just not worth the noise.

оригинал отзыва

ОмниКод-7AKTJ

20.01.2011

8/10

Оценка пользователя

Хорошо

I'm probably not the first one to do this, so I'll pass it on. Apparently a 'bare drive' is a drive with no parts, and not just a 'clean drive.' IE, it's an OEM drive, and there are no SATA cables, no screws, no SATA power converter cables, no manual, no factory provided hard drive tools for cloning, etc. I was a little surprised. I was able to get around what I assumed would have been provided, but I'm sure there are many customers who wouldn't have had the extra parts around.So, fair warning.

оригинал отзыва

КиберНаблюдатель-0KDGJ

16.02.2011

8/10

Оценка пользователя

Хорошо

Seagate Barracuda LP 2 TB 5900RPM SATA 3 GB/s 32 MB Cache 3.5-Inch Internal Hard Drive ST32000542AS-Bare DrivePurchased 2 of these hoping they would be a good deal. I have installed both drives in my HP Home Server. Each drive formatted out to 1.89 GB.I am in the burnin process now so I can not comment on reliability but I have purchased other Seagate drives with good results both in chassis and external.

оригинал отзыва

Супернова-6DDPP

07.02.2011

2/10

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

Seagate sucks! I will not buy from them again. It is WD or Hitachi from now on.I used this for 3 months and filled it 70%. Now it is dead! Will not spin up at all.Seagate said it CAN cost me over a $1K to get my data off. I have to send it in for a free evaluation. Pretty sure the price will go higher. I am pissed! I could have purchased 12 more drives with $1K and I would have 24TB of space or RAID 0 and make tons of copies.

оригинал отзыва

Интеллектор-6VAOZ

10.07.2010

8/10

Оценка пользователя

Хорошо

I Purchased 3 of these drives to be a part of a high availability raided NAS. Overall they are performing fine, but I could not give a higher mark due to some quality control issues.Pros:1) High Capacity2) Very quiet spin operation3) Slightly higher RPM then other green drives.4) Fast access time (Though my NAS is hardware limited to 50MB read, 30MB Write so the actual speed of the drive is unknown).Cons:1) Seems 1/4 drives arrive DOA. I got lucky2) One of my 3 is already 20% to the trouble threshold in high fly writes in S.M.A.R.T. It should pass this threshold in a month or so which will mean an RMA procedure.3) Drives park their heads automatically every 30 seconds - 1 minute. This operation is very loud. When contacting Seagate, it seems to be a "feature".4) Drive does not listen to standard hdparm options such as reduced accoustic modes.Overall, based on the performance so far and my uptime reliability, i would suggest this drive to friends, I just hope in the future seagate pays more attention to a drive's acoustics, especially during access or parking routines. It's horrible having a dead quiet rotation get interrupted every minute by a BANG!

оригинал отзыва

Квазар-4QLKH

01.09.2010

2/10

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

Amazon should not be selling an item like this. This drives conveniently fail right when the window to return them to Amazon closes, and you need to send them to Seagate who will just send you back the same 5900 rpm junk (even worst because Seagate turns around and sends you a refurbished one not a new one which is what you paid for) leaving you without a choice to change for a regular 7200rpm one. What is strange is that I have dealt with Seagate drives almost exclusively when I build PCs and this are the first drives that have let me down completely. Seagate drives usually carry a 5 year warranty, but this drives carry only a three year warranty so even Seagate does not have much confidence in this 5900 rpm drives. I can say for sure that I would not recommend this drive to anyone. Do not make the mistake I made of trusting the company reputation!Seagate Barracuda LP 2 TB 5900RPM SATA 3 GB/s 32 MB Cache 3.5-Inch Internal Hard Drive ST32000542AS-Bare Drive

оригинал отзыва

Плазмоид-7QXBK

05.04.2010

8/10

Оценка пользователя

Хорошо

I have had two of these drives operating continuously in a ReadyNAS storage device for the past three months and have just added a third. I have not experienced any of the failures or other problems that anybody here has described. All three disks, both the initial two and the third one that arrived more recently were well packaged in appropriate shock-insulating supports as well as in the manufacturer's anti-static foil bags. As expected, no instructions or other hardware were included which was not a problem given the intended use.These drives are not quite as quick as faster enterprise-level drives I've used, but quite adequate for my needs especially when used in an environment where network performance is probably the bottleneck rather than drive performance. Noise was a bit greater than I might have expected and temperatures were quite good. Compared to smaller Pipeline HD drives they replaced, these are faster, cooler but significantly noisier and I would not recommend them for a DVR or any other application where quiet operation is important. On a lark, I did try using one in a Netgear media player but got inconsistent results, apparently due to the fact that the startup time was too long.On the whole, I think the Barracuda LPs are an adequate lower-power alternative to enterprise drives in settings where maximum performance and minimum noise are not important criteria. Most likely will add a fourth to this array in the near future.

оригинал отзыва

ТехноНаблюдатель-5XNBW

28.11.2010

10/10

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

The seagate drives are awesome and they worked perfectly with my Synology 410j. They run very quiet and cool.What I don't like is Amazon's half assed pack job. I purchased 2 drives. Both were in an oversized box bumping around with nothing but a single pillow pack to keep them safe. Really Amazon? REALLY!? These are OEM units, not retail. That means absolutely no packaging. Just an anti-static bag.Amazon, if you're reading this, you guys need to get some schooling in proper hard drive packaging. Had you been sending this to Seagate the way it was shipped, it would have voided the warranty for sure. Do it right or don't do it at all.

оригинал отзыва

Астрономад-0QCQI

09.01.2011

8/10

Оценка пользователя

Хорошо

When I read the reviews on this drive, I initially passed them up. After the price dropped just before Christmas, they were too inexpensive pass up. I bought a couple and set them up in a RAID 1 external cabinet and set them as the backup device for Time Machine. After nearly a month of spinning full time, I haven't any issues with the drives. Additionally, the drives are much quieter than reports led me to believe. They are not as quiet as my Hitachi 2TB drives, but certainly not loud.

оригинал отзыва

Нейрон-3EDIZ

17.03.2011

4/10

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

Despite this drive being only 5900 rpm it worked great as an external drive. I say worked because after less than a year the drive failed on me. This is the second seagate drive I have had fail on me in two weeks. I will not buy another seagate drive.

оригинал отзыва

Аргонавт-3PSIL

12.04.2011

10/10

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Purchased this drive for my Windows Home Server (HP). I inserted the drive into the tray and added it to the drive pool, that was it.It's working great so far.

оригинал отзыва

Кронос-3JQOG

28.12.2010

10/10

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

i have it for a month now, and don't have any problems so far.i'm using it for storage to share data in a small home network(7 PCs), so far fast, quiet, and reliable.i bought the item for $70 so it is a good value. it runs at 5900 rpm but the drive is not slow compared with mine WD 7200 , i would say it performs a little better for now, it's not full though(30% of its capacity so far).the drive is good fro storage and general use, i would recommend this drive at the above price.

оригинал отзыва

Эксопилот-3YVGV

05.07.2010

10/10

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

I ordered 6 of these drives, 5 to put in Synology DS1010+ and one to keep on-hand for a spare. I ordered 3 drives from Amazon along with the Synology, and 3 drives from newegg. The 3 drives from Amazon are all "Made In China" and the 3 from newegg are "Made in Thailand". The Amazon drives were boxed individually and well protected, not able to bump around into each other during shipping.Over Gigabit Ethernet, the 5900RPM just won't be any issue. I still get over 110MB/sec transfers from the Synology. The drives have all been working fine and have passed multiple SMART tests.These drives DO take a few seconds to spin up if you allow them to spin down after idle. This will cause "freezes" if you use these in your PC, while the PC waits for the drive to spin up. If that's a problem for you, don't allow them to spin down in your power settings.The Synology DS1010+ and 5 drives together use about 55 Watts total. Very low power compared to leaving my main workstation on all the time (at least 250 Watts when idle). Now my HTPC and STB's can access shares when my main PC is off.

оригинал отзыва

Сатурниан-7SCXQ

17.03.2011

10/10

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Won't rehash what everyone's already said. These are great drives. I have about 15 of them on a ReadyaNAS network and multiple computers right now. They've been working great for months!

оригинал отзыва

Спектр-7OARX

07.04.2011

2/10

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

Amazon keeps delaying shipment of this drive, so although I ordered it over 20 days ago, I still can't review it.

оригинал отзыва

ХроноГость-7LJLP

06.02.2011

2/10

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

Four of these drives failed the SeaTools diagnostic out of the box. PeriodI have exclusively purchased Seagate drives for many years. Seagate needs to thoroughly review their entire QC department in China. Seagate is about to lose me as a long time customer since I can no longer trust their hard drives.

оригинал отзыва

Туманник-1DENP

06.03.2011

10/10

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Quiet, massive capacity, lower power consumption. Perfect for storage at 5900 rpm. It would be better with 64 MB cache though. Otherwise, a good drive. Faster and more reliable than WD Green drives.

оригинал отзыва

Показаны отзывы 73-96 из 163.

Отзывы о Жесткий диск Seagate Barracuda 1 ТБ ST31000520AS

163 отзывов пользователей o Seagate Barracuda 1 ТБ ST31000520AS

КиберНаблюдатель-7WLES

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Пульсар-0BNXO

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

Астрономад-8HQEK

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

Квазар-8CCGG

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Лунатик-6KVBG

Оценка пользователя

Хорошо

КиберНаблюдатель-5ZJHE

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Плазмоид-3BIJD

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Синтрон-1BSGR

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

ОмниКод-7AKTJ

Оценка пользователя

Хорошо

КиберНаблюдатель-0KDGJ

Оценка пользователя

Хорошо

Супернова-6DDPP

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

Интеллектор-6VAOZ

Оценка пользователя

Хорошо

Квазар-4QLKH

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

Плазмоид-7QXBK

Оценка пользователя

Хорошо

ТехноНаблюдатель-5XNBW

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Астрономад-0QCQI

Оценка пользователя

Хорошо

Нейрон-3EDIZ

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

Аргонавт-3PSIL

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Кронос-3JQOG

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Эксопилот-3YVGV

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Сатурниан-7SCXQ

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Спектр-7OARX

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

ХроноГость-7LJLP

Оценка пользователя

Ужасно

Туманник-1DENP

Оценка пользователя

Великолепно

Похожие товары с лучшей оценкой

Это Вам тоже может быть интересно